Who's Floyd's best win?

[Boxing lives]

Damn, you know your resume is ****ed up when your best win is ''Corrales'' or a over the hill ''DLH'', btw I think Floyd has great skills but you need to put those skills to test with the elite in their prime if you want to be considered a top ATG.

your clearly just a hater. Floyd also beat Roberto Guerrero. Guerrero's last name means soldier/warrior which clearly means he was dangerous. That was an unbelievable victory. Still not as good as the Ortiz win though. Floyd was utterly dominant in that win and showed his true nature and "killer instinct" with that brutal KO.

[Xi_]

and your point is?

my point is you have no point.

[The Tase]

my point is you have no point.

no wonder you're in the red.

crap answers.

crap poster.

btw, marquez is not floyd's best win.

[SeekDaGreat]

I'd say the Castillo rematch, personally. Especially if you think Mayweather lost the first fight, which I do.

I agree, because he knew Castillo had the tools to beat him and he knew he was going to have to box near perfect to get the win.

Castillo 2 is my choice. Huge win.

- Oscar was past his prime
- Mosely was past his prime
- Canelo is not completely developed

And I've never been too big on Hatton..

[UTEP]

Corrales.


Hatton would have been a real good win if it was fought at 140 instead of the weight where Hatton already lost to Luis Collazo, Hatton wasn't a welterweight.

[Xi_]

no wonder you're in the red.

crap answers.

crap poster.

btw, marquez is not floyd's best win.

show a poster who is in the red and i'll show a poster who doesn't gargle pac's ball's......if they don't gargle pac's balls and they're green it's because they've been here for years. furthermore, i never said marquez wasn;t his best but it is up there.

[Kuyukut]

i'd say josie harris is floyd's greatest win so far. he ko'ed josie in dos rounds with a liver punch. she is the one and only opponent that was brought to the hospital after the fight.

great win for floyd!

[-Kev-]

1. Hernandez
2. Corrales
3. Castillo
4. De La Hoya
5. Marquez
6. Hatton
7. Mosley
8. Cotto
9. Canelo
10. Unsure who to pick from Chavez/Judah/Baldomir

I think the Canelo win will grow in time.

Finally a good thread I don't have to lash out at. Hahaha. I would agree with the majority who picked a prime Chico. Oscar was old but had enough hand-speed and ring IQ to make it a fight through 8 rounds. It was a solid win. Canelo would've been his biggest win though had it not been for the catch-weight. He should've put a rehydration clause in the contract that stated what Canelo could not weigh over. The catch-weight was pointless and it made that win a little questionable. Good thread though.

Does the same apply to Pacquiao with his win over Miguel Cotto at a CW of 145?

[-Huey-]

I personally see the Corrales fight as his best performance, also his action packed fight against Augustus where Floyd had to dig deep...the Hatton fight was also another great performance as they were both undefeated. Floyd proved to have that extra gear that seperates the elite from the pretenders in those fights.

[Jack Napier]

1. Hernandez
2. Corrales
3. Castillo
4. De La Hoya
5. Marquez
6. Hatton
7. Mosley
8. Cotto
9. Canelo
10. Unsure who to pick from Chavez/Judah/Baldomir

I think the Canelo win will grow in time.



Does the same apply to Pacquiao with his win over Miguel Cotto at a CW of 145?

are you serious?