Who has the better resume, Nonito Donaire or JMM?

[Fighting_Pride]

let's look at donaire:
winner of world championship belts in 4 weight division. beat darchinyan in spectacular fashion (112 lbs). odds were 7-1. donaire won a belt at 115 and defended it a couple of times. he ko'ed montiel at 118, the first one to ever do it. won against vasquez, jr. at 122. he's currently gunning for a title at 126 this may against WBA featherweight "super" champion vetyeka.

as for marquez:
world champion in 4 different weight division. lost his first title (126 lbs) but eventually won it from medina, a guy who won the 126 belt an unbelieveble 4 separate times. marquez defended the belt 8 times (if you count the chris john fight as a win for marquez). he also won won against a faded barrera at 130. marquez ko'ed the very rugged casamayor at 135. he also won a belt at 140 but fought only once in the division. and oh yeah, he beat pacquiao.

it's kinda hard to choose.

your thoughts?

[Fighting_Pride]

what, no takers? i chose donaire by the way, based on the quality of opponents he fought

[Black Barty]

Donaire has a very deep and underrated resume, but frankly the Pacquiao KO trumps anything he has done so far.

So my choice is Marquez.

[Rapid Counter]

what, no takers? i chose donaire by the way, based on him being more Filipino than Marquez

Fixed it for ya bro

[CANELOLUJAH]

Fixed it for ya bro

you got it 100% correct.

[boliodogs]

I think Marquez has a better resume. Maybe Donaire will catch up but Marquez has fought the best around for many years with very few loses and some of those loses were bad decisions.

[jasjas]

[Flaco-N13]

wtf???

I don't know who is dumber, fighting pride for making this bulls..t of the year thread or me for even replying. WARQUEZ

[bojangles1987]

Someone would have to make a hell of a case to convince me of Donaire over Marquez. I don't see it at all.

[Black Barty]

Someone would have to make a hell of a case to convince me of Donaire over Marquez. I don't see it at all.

It's not as insane a comparison as the posters here are making it to be. Donaire has taken a lot of crap for the Rigo loss and his unimpressive showing in the Darch rematch, but he did beat ten current/former/future world titlist. It's the Pacquiao KO that tips the scale in Marquez's favor for me.