Official Mayweather vs Maidana Master Discussion & Postfight Analysis Thread

[turkas]

Mayweather won, but damn was it close. The 117-111 scorecard was completely unfair.

War Chino, man, war Chino. There are a lot of NSBers who should apologize for the stuff they've said about him. That was a great fight and the closest fight Floyd's been in in a very, very long time.

No doubt man. How many times did we try and tell people not to discredit Maidana. He brought and gave Floyd his toughest fight in years.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[-PBP-]

Here are the scorecards:




The 117-111 guy gave Mayweather the 8th and the 12th which I disagree with. Other than that I think they are pretty good scores.

[LoadedWraps]

No doubt man. How many times did we try and tell people not to discredit Maidana. He brought and gave Floyd his toughest fight in years.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

Chino fought his heart out and deserves a rematch, better conditioning and I think Chino can complete the upset or at very least make it a war. I am prou of Maidana and tons of people need to eat crow, I have been telling people for months Floyd is going to get tested but no one believed us.

[dc3383]

It was a great competitive fight but a fight in which Floyd won; it was the best fight I've been to.

[turkas]

Here are the scorecards:

IMAGE#1


The 117-111 guy gave Mayweather the 8th and the 12th which I disagree with. Other than that I think they are pretty good scores.

This shows a wide range in scores which shows us it was a very close fight.

Personally I had it a draw, but im biased and did see it in the arena so maybe not the best veiw. I gave chino 1 4 5 8 11 12. 11 was probably a floyd round but to me chino clearly won the others.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[kiaba360]

Chino fought his heart out and deserves a rematch, better conditioning and I think Chino can complete the upset or at very least make it a war. I am prou of Maidana and tons of people need to eat crow, I have been telling people for months Floyd is going to get tested but no one believed us.

Chino's conditioning held up better than I thought it would. I think 165lbs is too high a rehydration weight, and it's possible that he'd come in better shape for the rematch.

[PAKYO]

maidana sold his soul and dignity...he got cheated thrice and he's still happy with it.

[-PBP-]

This shows a wide range in scores which shows us it was a very close fight.

Personally I had it a draw, but im biased and did see it in the arena so maybe not the best veiw. I gave chino 1 4 5 8 11 12. 11 was probably a floyd round but to me chino clearly won the others.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

I had something very similar to you except I thought Floyd's work was much cleaner in the 11th. Maidana began roughing him up in the mid to late part of the round but wasn't doing a lot of clean, effective punching. I gave Floyd 9,10 and 11.

[sugarsmosley]

Chino would need better conditioning, i scored this fight a draw.

[big_james10]

Regardless of how many PPV's last night's fight sells, a rematch in September will sell two million PPVs. Schafer is probably already fielding calls from stars asking for comp tickets and Floyd and Schafer have already started counting the money.