Floyd's Resume

[Shambrolic]

Oscar robbed Pernell and a couple other fighters. Floyd also never fought anyone with a losing record, he always fought them critically acclaimed and coming off the biggest wins so he can steal their momentum. Kostya tzu, Hamed, Mosley, and Oscar including others ducked Floyd when he was at 135.

[jayblack]

better than nothing, i suppose... one good win and proclaimed himself the best fighter.

what a fucking fraud!

Actually the world proclaims him as the best fighter. Is there any P4P list that you know of where Mayweather isn't #1?

[jayblack]

Oscar robbed Pernell and a couple other fighters. Floyd also never fought anyone with a losing record, he always fought them critically acclaimed and coming off the biggest wins so he can steal their momentum. Kostya tzu, Hamed, Mosley, and Oscar including others ducked Floyd when he was at 135.

I think he was referring to Emanuel Agustus

[A-Wolf]

Genaro Hernandez, after 18 fights or something is a superb win, superb.

In Genaro's LAST ever fight. Yes, superb win.

[Larry the boss]

No he's not. If you want to talk about gifts, you should see the one they gave to Floyd in the first Castillo fight. Oscar also got some decisions not in his favor but that's boxing. Who exactly needed to fight each other to face him? I recall him facing most of the top guys in his division.



Nope but even if he was, people from the black power society wouldn't give him the credit he deserves.

yep when all else fails pull the race card

[4Corners]

At least he has one good win. That's something.

Genaro Hernandez: RING #1 SFW, undefeated at 130

Angel Manfredy: coming off win over prime Gatti, was #2 at 130

Diego Corrales: #1 at 130, undefeated, #5 P4P

Carlos Hernandez: Top 10 at 130, future champion

Jesus Chavez: Top 5 at 130, future 2 weight champion

Jose Luis Castillo: #1 130, best Lightweight of his era

DeMarcus Corley: Top 5 at 140, arguably beat Judah in the fight prior

Arturo Gatti: Top 5 at 140

Zab Judah: Top 5 at 147

Carlos Baldomir: RING CHAMP 147, coming off win over Judah

Oscar De La Hoya: Top 5 at 154

Ricky Hatton: #1 140, Top 10 P4P, undefeated

Juan Manuel Marquez: Bullcrap fight at the time, would go on to KO Pac at same weight class

Shane Mosley: #1-2 147, #3 P4P

Victor Ortiz: #2 147

Miguel Cotto: #1 at 154

Robert Guerrero: Top 5 at 147

Canelo Alvarez: RING CHAMP 154, undefeated, coming off win over Trout



All of these are either decent, solid, or really good wins. That's the best resume currently aside from Pacquiao, and it's closer then ever given Manny hasn't actually gotten a legit win aside from Bradley since Cotto and Clottey.

[A-Wolf]

Genaro Hernandez: RING #1 SFW, undefeated at 130

Angel Manfredy: coming off win over prime Gatti, was #2 at 130

Diego Corrales: #1 at 130, undefeated, #5 P4P

Carlos Hernandez: Top 10 at 130, future champion

Jesus Chavez: Top 5 at 130, future 2 weight champion

Jose Luis Castillo: #1 130, best Lightweight of his era

DeMarcus Corley: Top 5 at 140, arguably beat Judah in the fight prior

Arturo Gatti: Top 5 at 140

Zab Judah: Top 5 at 147

Carlos Baldomir: RING CHAMP 147, coming off win over Judah

Oscar De La Hoya: Top 5 at 154

Ricky Hatton: #1 140, Top 10 P4P, undefeated

Juan Manuel Marquez: Bullcrap fight at the time, would go on to KO Pac at same weight class

Shane Mosley: #1-2 147, #3 P4P

Victor Ortiz: #2 147

Miguel Cotto: #1 at 154

Robert Guerrero: Top 5 at 147

Canelo Alvarez: RING CHAMP 154, undefeated, coming off win over Trout



All of these are either decent, solid, or really good wins. That's the best resume currently aside from Pacquiao, and it's closer then ever given Manny hasn't actually gotten a legit win aside from Bradley since Cotto and Clottey.

Whatever you say, man.

[4Corners]

Oh and Oscar isn't greater then Mayweather. No way.

Oscar lost to Trinidad, though it was close. He arguably lost to Whitaker. Lost to Mosley, though he arguably won at least one fight, and lost to Hopkins. He also arguably lost to Sturm. He lost a lot of his big fights.

Now he's still got good wins over Ruelas, Genaro, Chavez, Gonzalez, Quartey, Carr, Gatti, Vargas, etc.

And given he probably deserved the Trinidad fight, and at least one Mosley fight, he's an ATG and lock HOF fighter. But he's not greater then Mayweather. And Mayweather easily has the longevity battle won. He's been one of the top P4P fighters since 1998. That's over 15 years. Oscar was only P4P for maybe half that time.

[4Corners]

Whatever you say, man.

Good argument.

[UTEP]

Genaro Hernandez: RING #1 SFW, undefeated at 130

Angel Manfredy: coming off win over prime Gatti, was #2 at 130

Diego Corrales: #1 at 130, undefeated, #5 P4P

Carlos Hernandez: Top 10 at 130, future champion

Jesus Chavez: Top 5 at 130, future 2 weight champion

Jose Luis Castillo: #1 130, best Lightweight of his era

DeMarcus Corley: Top 5 at 140, arguably beat Judah in the fight prior

Arturo Gatti: Top 5 at 140
Zab Judah: Top 5 at 147

Carlos Baldomir: RING CHAMP 147, coming off win over Judah

Oscar De La Hoya: Top 5 at 154

Ricky Hatton: #1 140, Top 10 P4P, undefeated

Juan Manuel Marquez: Bullcrap fight at the time, would go on to KO Pac at same weight class
Shane Mosley: #1-2 147, #3 P4P

Victor Ortiz: #2 147

Miguel Cotto: #1 at 154

Robert Guerrero: Top 5 at 147

Canelo Alvarez: RING CHAMP 154, undefeated, coming off win over Trout


All of these are either decent, solid, or really good wins. That's the best resume currently aside from Pacquiao, and it's closer then ever given Manny hasn't actually gotten a legit win aside from Bradley since Cotto and Clottey.