Whos your #10 P4P

[Bushbaby]

Come on bush baby, your a PAC and Floyd basher. One of the few in this forum. Your not bias. Your just a consistent basher of the 2 btw I did pick you as one of the names I chose for poster of the year nominations before poll came out.

My list is based off these 3 things in the following order:

1) recent wins against best in division
2) career accomplishments
3) excitement

Thank you for the shout out appreciate it. But on point, if recent wins and excitement are your criteria, or 2 of your 3, then realistically Ward and Rigo wouldn't be top 3. Now I myself find both entertaining, but the majority of fans, some strange don't.

Furthermore if career accomplishments can keep a fighter in the the current top pfp list, that would make it impossible for the young fighters who demonstrate fabulous talent no room to improve as long as an atg is active correct?? That's not fair.

Pacman for instance has done nothing in years to be worthy of top 5 pfp at the end of 2013. All he did was get slept and beat a fighter who was foreign to his division recently. Coincidentally the fighter who ko'd him is not in your op 5. That's certainly unfair to him, no??

[NEETzsche]

1. mayweather
2. ward
3. rigondeaux
4. bradley
5. pacquiao
6. w. klitschko
7. j. m. marquez
8. d. garcia
9. m. garcia
10. kovalev

[jas]

Thank you for the shout out appreciate it. But on point, if recent wins and excitement are your criteria, or 2 of your 3, then realistically Ward and Rigo wouldn't be top 3. Now I myself find both entertaining, but the majority of fans, some strange don't.

Furthermore if career accomplishments can keep a fighter in the the current top pfp list, that would make it impossible for the young fighters who demonstrate fabulous talent no room to improve as long as an atg is active correct?? That's not fair.

Pacman for instance has done nothing in years to be worthy of top 5 pfp at the end of 2013. All he did was get slept and beat a fighter who was foreign to his division recently. Coincidentally the fighter who ko'd him is not in your op 5. That's certainly unfair to him, no??

Rigo beat the best guy in his division this year In donaire. He would be fav to beat all the guys around his division such as abner or Jhonny but we won't get to see it because of promoters.

Ward has cleaned out his division. Rodriguez was one of the best 168 pounders he hadn't already beat yet.

It's a combo of all 3 criteria with excitement being least important..

Ok so JMM beat PAC but PAC beat Bradley in most people eyes but Bradley beat JMM. So how do you want me to order these 3? The way I do it is to ask myself which of the 3 beats the top 10 in their division the most and it's PAC.

[Bushbaby]

Rigo beat the best guy in his division this year In donaire. He would be fav to beat all the guys around his division such as abner or Jhonny but we won't get to see it because of promoters.

Ward has cleaned out his division. Rodriguez was one of the best 168 pounders he hadn't already beat yet.

It's a combo of all 3 criteria with excitement being least important..

Ok so JMM beat PAC but PAC beat Bradley in most people eyes but Bradley beat JMM. So how do you want me to order these 3? The way I do it is to ask myself which of the 3 beats the top 10 in their division the most and it's PAC.

Pacman beats most of the top 10 in his division?? Are you sure? He's beaten 1 prime welterweight in his entire run there (and needed a catchweight to do it). Well he beat Clottey too. Don't even know if he even had a prime honestly. Right now Bradley should be ranked higher than Marquez who ranks higher than Pacman. He's the youngest, freshest and has more of an elite hof career left.

[Rome-By-Ko]

Rigo beat the best guy in his division this year In donaire. He would be fav to beat all the guys around his division such as abner or Jhonny but we won't get to see it because of promoters.

Ward has cleaned out his division. Rodriguez was one of the best 168 pounders he hadn't already beat yet.

It's a combo of all 3 criteria with excitement being least important..

Ok so JMM beat PAC but PAC beat Bradley in most people eyes but Bradley beat JMM. So how do you want me to order these 3? The way I do it is to ask myself which of the 3 beats the top 10 in their division the most and it's PAC.

Bradley Marquez Pac..That should be your order..

Pac beating the top 10 in the div is not a lock..Hell he loss to two of the top 10 already dude..

[tommyknocker]

Bradley Marquez Pac..That should be your order..

Pac beating the top 10 in the div is not a lock..Hell he loss to two of the top 10 already dude..

I suppose you are a very biased Bradley-Fan, if you think he beat Pac.

[Rome-By-Ko]

I suppose you are a very biased Bradley-Fan, if you think he beat Pac.

Obviously you've missed the point..Must be your butt hurt blocking you vision..

Oh and BTW I like Pac as well as Bradley..

[tommyknocker]

Obviously you've missed the point..Must be your butt hurt blocking you vision..

Oh and BTW I like Pac as well as Bradley..

neither fan of Bradley or Pac. that about the butthurt


but to say Bradley beat Pac is very ignorant and shows the conformity with bull**** decisions. that's sad

[Jloro]

Rigo should not be in the top 10.... GGG should take his spot imo.

1. Floyd
2. Ward
3. Wlad
4. D. Garcia
5. M. Pacquiao
6. M. Garcia
7. GGG
8. Bradley
9. Canelo
10. Froch

lol thats a funny joke

[tommyknocker]

1. Floyd Maywether
2. Andre Ward
3. Guillermo Rigondeaux
4. Tim Bradley
5. Manny Pacquiao
6. Danny Garcia
7. Juan Manuel Marquez
8. Mikey Garcia
9. Sergio Martinez
10. Roman Gonzalez