What if...Jermian Taylor

[Easy-E]

Ok, so i a going into what if's for jermian this year.
Say he fights winky and wins a clear decision. then me fights arthur abraham or kassim ouma late in this year and wins another ocnvincing fight. where does he go p4p

[GunStar]

Ok, so i a going into what if's for jermian this year.
Say he fights winky and wins a clear decision. then me fights arthur abraham or kassim ouma late in this year and wins another ocnvincing fight. where does he go p4p

He will be #2. I have him #3 right now.

PBF
Pac
Taylor

[RAESAAD]

He will be #2. I have him #3 right now.

PBF
Pac
Taylor

He may be 3 if he does that he is in the 8-10 range for me right now.

[DiegoFuego]

if you don't have Taylor top 5, you don't need to be ranking anything

[RAESAAD]

if you don't have Taylor top 5, you don't need to be ranking anything

Well thats a matter of opinion why do you think because if someone does not agree with you they have no business scoring or ranking? Taylor is not in the top 5 p4p now and if anyone has him there they don't deserve to be ranking.

[GunStar]

if you don't have Taylor top 5, you don't need to be ranking anything

Exactly. He beat the so called #1 P4P guy in Hopkins twice. Oh know Hopkins nuthugger will attack me now

[restless_438]

Ok, so i a going into what if's for jermian this year.
Say he fights winky and wins a clear decision. then me fights arthur abraham or kassim ouma late in this year and wins another ocnvincing fight. where does he go p4p

that's a pretty good question.. right now, i probably have him at #11. i'd say if he clearly beats Wright, no questions or controversy, he'd be in the #4-#7 range.. if he goes on to fight and beat Abraham, Karmazin, or Ouma.. i'd put him at #3-4. He wouldn't be higher than Pacman or Mayweather unless he really pulls off some impressive couple of fights.

Keep in mind if he beats Wright, Ouma, anyone etc., i don't want to have to see these "close decision, could've really given it to either fighter" type of fights, it better be clear.

[RAESAAD]

that's a pretty good question.. right now, i probably have him at #11. i'd say if he clearly beats Wright, no questions or controversy, he'd be in the #4-#7 range.. if he goes on to fight and beat Abraham, Karmazin, or Ouma.. i'd put him at #3-4. He wouldn't be higher than Pacman or Mayweather unless he really pulls off some impressive couple of fight.

Thank you for bringing some reason back into this thread. Like my new avatar?

[SuckaPunch]

Ok, so i a going into what if's for jermian this year.
Say he fights winky and wins a clear decision. then me fights arthur abraham or kassim ouma late in this year and wins another ocnvincing fight. where does he go p4p

The keyword is CONVINCING win. If he does all of them in a very clear fashion, possibly a few KO wins against the top middleweights, then he sure is a top3 P4P player.

Now, it also depends on the future of PBF & Pac. Say Floyd beats Cotto, Hatton, Margarito and Pac beats Barrera, Marquez, Barrios, then Jermaine stays at #3(unless he goes up and beats Lacy @ 168 )

[GunStar]

that's a pretty good question.. right now, i probably have him at #11. i'd say if he clearly beats Wright, no questions or controversy, he'd be in the #4-#7 range.. if he goes on to fight and beat Abraham, Karmazin, or Ouma.. i'd put him at #3-4. He wouldn't be higher than Pacman or Mayweather unless he really pulls off some impressive couple of fights.

Keep in mind if he beats Wright, Ouma, anyone etc., i don't want to have to see these "close decision, could've really given it to either fighter" type of fights, it better be clear.

What number you put Winky right now???