Maidana's biggest victory is against Broner. (Does that really say much?)

[Haterfree]

Maidana is a B level WW at his absolute best. Losses to Amir Khan & Devon Alexander don't exactly make him stand out as unbeatable. In all honesty I think Amir Khan & Devon Alexander would both beat Broner too. Comparing Maidana to a great fighter like Manny P & saying he could beat a great fighter like Floyd is absurd.

[damuttz112]

It's quite funny, Khan's wins against Judah, Malignaggi and Maidana are looking better as time goes on.

[Dr Rumack]

Maidana's ordinary, but he gets respect because of how he carries himself in and out of the ring.

Broner....

[Bushbaby]

No no no, It's Maidana who beat Broner. Doesn't do any good for Khan or Devon. Devon just got his a$$ whooped and Khan has yet to do anything of note since Danny took up the role of his step daddy.

[Beercules]

Aw hold on, here you go

[Evil Abed]

He's better now than he was when he loss to Khan and Alexander. He's a very tough guy to beat right now. Clearly not unbeatable. Nobody has said that. He has some good wins. Lopez, Karass, Konlenik, Broner, Ortiz,. Pretty solid run.

[Haterfree]

No no no, It's Maidana who beat Broner. Doesn't do any good for Khan or Devon. Devon just got his a$$ whooped and Khan has yet to do anything of note since Danny took up the role of his step daddy.

I think its safe to say that Khan, Devon, & Danny would all beat Broner at WW.

[915]

No I think it was against Ortiz. We wouldn't even be talking about Maidana if he lost that fight.

[Bushbaby]

I think its safe to say that Khan, Devon, & Danny would all beat Broner at WW.

I honestly don't see how it's safe to say Khan could beat any decent punching welterweight right now......well maybe he could beat Broner today. But not when he's trained, healed and healthy.

[Jam Jars]

Nobody is saying Maidana is a great fighter, so I don't see the point of the thread.