Broner or Judah... Who actually did Better Against Malignaggi?

[dannyl15]

Are you denying that both Judah and Broner's output was reduced quite significantly due to Malignaggi's style? Did you watch both those fights? They were similar in the respect that both Judah and Broner were kept on the defensive for large parts of the fights.. Watch them again and you'll see what I mean.

I don't think anybody is denying that Malignaggi's style gave either fighter problem's but the Judah fight was a clear shut out and the broner fight was pretty close.

[boliodogs]

Broner did better by far of course. Broner clearly won a fairly close fight. Judah clearly lost and the fight was not even close.

[nauti4life85]

Both those fights followed a similar pattern where both Broner and Judah were almost stunned into silence for large parts of the fight, confused by Paulie's output and movement, but who do you think performed better against Malignaggi - was it Broner or Judah?

Yes Paulie's style gave them both problems but in the Judah fight Paulie controlled the action, had ring generalship, landed more punches, and turned Judah's offense completely off. In the Broner fight while Paulie did have success here and there, Broner had way better ring generalship, landed more punches even though his total punches were low, and had Paulie on his bicycle for majority of the fight. Also there's a thing called effective punching which Paulie lacked in the Broner fight. I know some people want to count punches on the arms and elbows but im sorry it does not count as a landed shot. Can we please stop having these threads? Paulie clearly lost vs Broner but I'm betting he does better in a rematch if he can attempt to do what he did vs Judah. He said Broner can't crack so imo set up the rematch and Paulie should be able to repeat his performance from Saturday night if he doesn't get on his bicycle.

[DannYankee]

Broner ofc Judah reeeeaaaaaally bad Broner was just regular bad.