Post your new top 10 p4p list

[Dirk Diggler UK]

around the same time froch did

What does that even mean? Another female trait is to making completely unrelated statements in an argument.

[New England]

What does that even mean? Another female trait is to making completely unrelated statements in an argument.

classic bscene tactic, intentional or otherwise.

[littlemac]

1-Manny
2-Shiming
3-Donaire
4-Rios
5-Bradley
6-Wlad
7-Juan
8-Canelo
9-Ward
10-Floyd

[teddycanyon]

1. Floyd
2. Ward
3. Bradley
4. Wlad
5. JMM
6. Pac
7. Rigo
8. Swift
9. Donaire
10. Matthysse
Froch was #9 going into yesterday, but I dropped him down to #16 on my personal list. And Manny was #7 but I moved him ahead of Rigo with the Rios win.

[teddycanyon]

floyd
ward
manny
bradley
jmm
martinez
wlad
rigo
d garcia
m garcia

I don't think you can put Manny over Bradley. Pac got KTFO by Marquez and Bradley beat Marquez. Triangle theory, yes but that does mean something. Additionally, when Pacquiao and Bradley fought, Bradley had a badly injured foot and could not get out of the way of any of Pac's shots, so we have yet to see how a healthy Bradley would fare in there with Pacquiao. No shortage of great names on Bradley's resume either, including Provodnikov, and that win looks a lot better in hindsight. For the time being, Bradley's gotta be ranked ahead of both Pacquiao and Marquez and is either #3 or #4 P4P.

[Tay Roc]

I don't think you can put Manny over Bradley. Pac got KTFO by Marquez and Bradley beat Marquez. Triangle theory, yes but that does mean something. Additionally, when Pacquiao and Bradley fought, Bradley had a badly injured foot and could not get out of the way of any of Pac's shots, so we have yet to see how a healthy Bradley would fare in there with Pacquiao. No shortage of great names on Bradley's resume either, including Provodnikov, and that win looks a lot better in hindsight. For the time being, Bradley's gotta be ranked ahead of both Pacquiao and Marquez and is either #3 or #4 P4P.

So you're saying Bradley should be ahead of Pac because of triangle theory, Bradley hurt his ankles and Bradley's resume? I have Manny ahead because he clearly outclassed Bradley in their fight, barely losing any rounds. I would have JMM ahead of Pac, but he lost his most recent fight, so that naturally moves him down (and below Bradley who defeated him).

I think you make very poor arguments. First, triangle theory is BS because you could use it to make the exact opposite argument. Second, injuries happen in fights. Bradley was hurt because Pacquaio was crossing him up and making him twist his own ankles trying to dodge Pac. It's a weak excuse for getting outclassed and outworked. Pac's resume has legends on it, Bradley's has one legend on it (JMM). So that's not a fair comparison either.

You're only real arguments in favor of Bradley over Pac is that his last victory was much better than Pac's, and Pac was KO'd in his fight before Rios. Those are more fair arguments that have merit. I would respect having Bradley over Pac for those reasons, but not for the ones you stated.

[mathed]

Floyd
Martinez
Bradley
Ward
Wlad
JMM
Pac
Froch
Rigo
M. Garcia

[SlySlickSmooth]

1. Danny Garcia
2. Danny Garcia
3. Danny Garcia
4. Danny Garcia
5. Danny Garcia
6. Danny Garcia
7. Danny Garcia
8. Danny Garcia
9. Danny Garcia
10. Danny Garcia

[New England]

So you're saying Bradley should be ahead of Pac because of triangle theory, Bradley hurt his ankles and Bradley's resume? I have Manny ahead because he clearly outclassed Bradley in their fight, barely losing any rounds. I would have JMM ahead of Pac, but he lost his most recent fight, so that naturally moves him down (and below Bradley who defeated him).

I think you make very poor arguments. First, triangle theory is BS because you could use it to make the exact opposite argument. Second, injuries happen in fights. Bradley was hurt because Pacquaio was crossing him up and making him twist his own ankles trying to dodge Pac. It's a weak excuse for getting outclassed and outworked. Pac's resume has legends on it, Bradley's has one legend on it (JMM). So that's not a fair comparison either.

You're only real arguments in favor of Bradley over Pac is that his last victory was much better than Pac's, and Pac was KO'd in his fight before Rios. Those are more fair arguments that have merit. I would respect having Bradley over Pac for those reasons, but not for the ones you stated.

you should have rained down the thunder on rios last night. give him some of that macao power for talking back to maxie.

[sparkman0811]

1-Manny
2-Floyd
3-Ward
4-Rios
5-Bradley
6-Wlad
7-Juan
8-Canelo
9-Garcia
10-Donaire

Good man. I used to think you didn't know **** about boxing, but I was wrong.