where would you rate Pacquiao on ATG list if

[fight_professor]

Come what may, Pac will be high on the p4p ATG list when he retires.

[HanzGruber]

Even if PAC beat Floyd hed still be way behind him

[soul_survivor]

no offense because i really like you as a poster, but how the hell is demspey and arguello ahead of manny now...

Manny has accomplished more at 135 and under to, let alone at the higher weights, then both of those guys ever did,,

dempsey dodged all black competitior like harry wills and sam langford,, and got whipped everytime he really stepped up like vs tunney

arguello was a beautiful boxer to watch but his career accomplishments arent greater than manny's

manny's epic fights with mab, morales, jmm are better than anything those guys did,, and then add on the hatton, cotto, margs, clottey, etc

demspey gets blown out of the water,,, arguello is close, but he didnt do nearly enough to surpass manny's career accomplishments

Non taken, I just think Dempsey was the most dominant heavyweight of his era and the most feared fighter of the decade. When he eventually faced Tunney, he'd been out of the ring for 3 years and was never the same again. Arguello has great achievements but yes, Manny overtakes him but I think, from the fights I've seen, that Arguello was more skilled, better combinations, terrific speed and agility (Manny trumps him on speed) and good solid power.

TBH, there are names in my list from 35-40 that could easily be interchangeable. If you place him higher, no problem but he shouldn't be any higher than 30.

[soul_survivor]

Even if PAC beat Floyd hed still be way behind him

that's ******ed

[bojangles1987]

Top 25 at least.

[solo20]

top 50-30
if anyone has him below that THEN YOU DONT KNOW CRAP ABOUT BOXING PERIOD not to surprise many have him below that this is boxingscene after all

[lets rumble]

hes gotta be up there in the top 20.
pac fans gunna beleive higher than floyd
but boxing fans no that aint true

[Pacdbest]

Pac was already in the top 10 when he beat up 3 HOFamers JMM, EM & Barrera. After he KO DLH, he's already top 5, Beating Cotto was Just a Bonus. Losing to JMM doesn't change anything. Bradley was a dominating win for him. He's already top 3. Beating Floyd make him No 1.

[lets rumble]

Pac was already in the top 10 when he beat up 3 HOFamers JMM, EM & Barrera. After he KO DLH, he's already top 5, Beating Cotto was Just a Bonus. Losing to JMM doesn't change anything. Bradley was a dominating win for him. He's already top 3. Beating Floyd make him No 1.

not at the moment , we talking about best of all time,
no way pac top 5

[MrTambourineMan]

Even if PAC beat Floyd hed still be way behind him

[IMG]http://ist2-2.filesor.com/***********.com/2/2/4/3/22438/1/L/H/G/1LHGS/goose-laughing.gif[/IMG]

:*******: