Judges shouldn't score fights from ringside anymore

[Calm down mate]

That's a good idea. I still like my idea if having 9 or 11 judges kinda like figure skating which would nullify the couple of ******s and blind judges.

I like that because it means paying them off will cost more then

[Tay Roc]

Judges should have access to Max Kellerman's commentary while they score. Also, he should be able to show them his card during the fight, since his card's are always perfect.

[Rockin']

horrible idea. the trouble through time has been honesty, changing the view will change nothing. These guys know what they see............ Rockin'

[sugarsmosley]

What about putting em in a room, and MUTING the damn audio?

or is that too far?

[JDezi4]

What about putting em in a room, and MUTING the damn audio?

or is that too far?

Well, I was thinking they would have new specially built TV's that don't have sound

Lol, excuse me for not clarifying exactly how the TV becomes silent...

[JDezi4]

horrible idea. the trouble through time has been honesty, changing the view will change nothing. These guys know what they see............ Rockin'

Is it a horrible idea, or do u just think it won't work?

[jaded]

Watching a fight on TV or a monitor DOES NOT accurately represent the fight. I have worked on film and TV sets and where fight scenes were being shot and thought what I was seeing would never fly in a million years. Then a few months later I'd see it on TV and think wow they really pulled it off.

The camera angle changes everything and can make a punch that is almost a foot away look like a connect. This is why sometimes what looks like a major misjudging from your living room something that the judges ringside saw very differently. A guy can snap his head out of the way of a punch that missed and look on TV as a punch that snapped the guy's head back because the camera was more over the shoulder's POV. I'm not saying judges don't get it wrong sometimes but you are not seeing the same fight on TV as they do ringside...so it really is a terrible idea.

[JDezi4]

Watching a fight on TV or a monitor DOES NOT accurately represent the fight. I have worked on film and TV sets and where fight scenes were being shot and thought what I was seeing would never fly in a million years. Then a few months later I'd see it on TV and think wow they really pulled it off.

The camera angle changes everything and can make a punch that is almost a foot away look like a connect. This is why sometimes what looks like a major misjudging from your living room something that the judges ringside saw very differently. A guy can snap his head out of the way of a punch that missed and look on TV as a punch that snapped the guy's head back because the camera was more over the shoulder's POV. I'm not saying judges don't get it wrong sometimes but you are not seeing the same fight on TV as they do ringside...so it really is a terrible idea.

This is kinda of a contradiction... I mean, if camera being at the wrong angle at the wrong time effects how some punches look when they land/don't land than how will being in one static position going to help??

I'm pretty sure judges missed MOST of the work Lara put in against Vanes Martirosyan was stuff u can only see from the right camera angle, which is why that fight ended up a draw...

Camera's may not catch everything, but they catch more than someone possibly could sitting at a table on one side of the ring

[TX_BOXNG]

Lol these judges know how to score there has been crazy scoring for a while, its not cuase they cant score its because they are paid off its so obvious

Last night the judges had Darchynian winning, but do you really think the same score cards would of been turned in if it would gone the distance, Rigondeaux was schooling Nonito easy he didnt win a round he jist scored a KD n he still came close to winning in 2 of the cards

[Rome-By-Ko]

Nah,I like the way fights have been being judge throughout the yrs..They just need to train the judges better tbh..This sport is subjective,I like that about it,leave the sport how it is..