If Stevenson wins, he should be FOTY

[$Bullsfam$]

He should but he will get robbed. Fn boxing political ****s


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[MRCHOKEaMF]

Pretty boy floyd Joy Money Mayweather. Defended his Junior Middleweight Championship (in a record setting fight), dominated his opponent who many said he would lose to, Defended his Welterweight Championship by domination, Ring p4p championship by domination, for christ sake he's now the Supreme WBC Champion. How can it be anyone else, except for maybe Danny. Its has to go to the absolute greatest, supreme, TWO division champion who defended two different weight class titles. They have to look for middleweights and above to test him no ones close to him, hell Pac doesnt even have a belt to speak of so he's no challenge.

I know it makes you mad. (you know who you are)

[SlySlickSmooth]

Pretty boy floyd Joy Money Mayweather. Defended his Junior Middleweight Championship (in a record setting fight), dominated his opponent who many said he would lose to, Defended his Welterweight Championship by domination, Ring p4p championship by domination, for christ sake he's now the Supreme WBC Champion. How can it be anyone else, except for maybe Danny. Its has to go to the absolute greatest, supreme, TWO division champion who defended two different weight class titles. They have to look for middleweights and above to test him no ones close to him, hell Pac doesnt even have a belt to speak of so he's no challenge.

I know it makes you mad. (you know who you are)

This is a post by the misinformed that are "informed"

Mayweather shouldn't even be considered AT ALL for FOTY when dudes Rigondeaux is alive.

Canelo being at #1 for JMW was the biggest joke ever.

[Cuban Linx]

Well if he blows out Bellew then he'll likely get it.

[VatoMulatto]

I'm more impressed with KOvalev's resume to be honest. Campillo, White, Cleverly, Sillakh>>> Boone, Dawson, Cloud, Bellew

Boone is a solid journeyman but nothing special. Chad is just done and was overrated to begin with. Campillo beat Cloud, who was outclassed by an ancient B Hop. Cleverly beat Bellew. Idk I think What Kovalev has done is more impressive. Yeah you can say Adonis beat the number 1 in the division, but does anyone really know what Dawson has left? The guy just got stopped by Ward...

Dawson is better than Campillo White and Cleverly....Adonis KO win over Dawson is better than any of Kovalev's wins. If Adonis beats Bellew he should have a really good chance to be FOTY.

[Black Barty]

At the very least for the Ring Magazine.

Hate him or love him, he had a very active year with 3 of his 4 fights being against Ring Top 10 opposition.
He blasted out the Ring champion, battered Cloud into submission and is now taking on another top 10 opponent in his weight class.
I won't argue that it's debatable though.
Dawson was knocked out in his last fight, but at 168
Cloud was coming off a loss to Hopkins and was never that impressive
Bellew is coming off those debatable fights against Chilemba

Still though, he's fighting people who're recognized at the top of his weight class and beating them.

I don't think he should be FOTY, for the exact reasons you listed. Imo Bradley, Danny Garcia, Mikey Garcia (if he beats Martinez), Rigo (if he beats Agbeko), Sosa (if he beats Yaegashi) and heck, even Floyd had a better campaign this year.

Stevenson's quality of opp this year is clearly worse than Donaire's was last year, and I recall many saying Donaire shouldn't be FOTY because he didn't beat "elite" opponents.

[BUNGALOWS]

Bradley has the best case, IMO.

Beat Ruslan (Ruslan's win over Alvarado makes it that much better). Different weight classes, but whatever.

Beat JMM.

[paulf]

As much as I hate him, I agree.

[Cuban Linx]

I don't think he should be FOTY, for the exact reasons you listed. Imo Bradley, Danny Garcia, Mikey Garcia (if he beats Martinez), Rigo (if he beats Agbeko), Sosa (if he beats Yaegashi) and heck, even Floyd had a better campaign this year.

Stevenson's quality of opp this year is clearly worse than Donaire's was last year, and I recall many saying Donaire shouldn't be FOTY because he didn't beat "elite" opponents.

IMO it all depends on how you rate Chad Dawson. Was Chad Dawson a hype job or was he a legit challenger at the time. I think it's somewhere in between with Dawson. I mean lets be honest he built his whole career beating up 40 year olds.

Rigo won't get it. HBO blacklisted him after he schooled Donaire. He has an irrelevant fight against Agbeko in December. He should have fought at least once more since the Donaire fight by now. It's a shame because he would have the best case right now.

Danny Garcia and Bradley also have strong arguments.

[apocalypto]

It should be adonis or sosa. Even estrada has a great case. Beating viloria and melindo was a great feat