Who has the better resume in terms of better wins - Mayweather or Pacquiao?

[Lords]

Barrera had already been through wars with 61 fights under his belt when Manny fought him. Morales was coming off a UD loss to Raheem when Manny avenged his loss from their first fight. 145 pound DLH? An already KO'd Hatton? 145 pound Cotto? Clottey off a loss? Margarita off a KO and year suspension? Shane? I also have JMM outboxing Manny in their first 3 fights. I like Manny but his resume is not better than Floyd's.

[AnKhang]

Pac definitely have the better resume. The 3 Mexicans alone are all future HoF. Floyd is a cherry picker that's why he's got nothing in his resume but his 0.

[hugh grant]

Floyd fans say Pac hasn't beat anyone Floyd wouldn't beat? But the reality is Floyd hasn't beat anyone Pac wouldn't beat, but Pac fights p4p fighters more regularly. When Pac fought and beat JMM, Pac says next victim, and then the fight with Bradley is signed, after being robbed by Bradley, pac says next. Then he signs to fight JMM within 6 months. One p4p fighter after another is what you get with Pac.

Not only does Pac beat everyone Floyd beats he ko's them out. Floyd don't. Floyd fans were going on about JMM koing Pac so that means more than Pacs decision wins over JMM somehow they make you believe.
So Pacs ko wins far outweigh anything Floyd has done.

[mannyman]

Pacquiao fights Mayweather's leftovers. real talk.

How do you work that one out? Mayweather fought Cotto and Marquez after PAc had dealt with them.

They fought each others opponents you mug.

[A-Wolf]

Pacquiao by a country mile.

[mannyman]

Barrera had already been through wars with 61 fights under his belt when Manny fought him. Morales was coming off a UD loss to Raheem when Manny avenged his loss from their first fight. 145 pound DLH? An already KO'd Hatton? 145 pound Cotto? Clottey off a loss? Margarita off a KO and year suspension? Shane? I also have JMM outboxing Manny in their first 3 fights. I like Manny but his resume is not better than Floyd's.

Mayweather fought a 140lb fighter in Hatton and brought him to WW.

Mayweather fought an older war torn version of Cotto.

Mayweather fought a bloated LW in Marquez.

Mayweather fought a weight drained Canelo.

Also FYI - DLH choose PAC and set the terms - he was still boxings cash cow at that point AND was heavily favoured to beat PAC. It was Pacs first fight at WW.

I'm not hating on Mayweather here - but please get your facts right kid. They're both as bad as each other for trying to gain an advantage over their opponents.

[Pacquiao'd]

Mayweather fought a 140lb fighter in Hatton and brought him to WW.

Mayweather fought an older war torn version of Cotto.

Mayweather fought a bloated LW in Marquez.

Mayweather fought a weight drained Canelo.

Also FYI - DLH choose PAC and set the terms - he was still boxings cash cow at that point AND was heavily favoured to beat PAC. It was Pacs first fight at WW.

I'm not hating on Mayweather here - but please get your facts right kid. They're both as bad as each other for trying to gain an advantage over their opponents.

Well Floyd fought a non drained cotto and Dlh, a confident hatton he ko first, beat Marquez easily who later ko PAC at a higher weight and an undefeated canelo who wasn't drained, better version of Mosley coming off wins.

You lawst. Now get your " facts" straight

[PAC-BOY]

Well Floyd fought a non drained cotto and Dlh, a confident hatton he ko first, beat Marquez easily who later ko PAC at a higher weight and an undefeated canelo who wasn't drained, better version of Mosley coming off wins.

You lawst

Just shut up and look at the poll.:WORD:

[miron_lang]

people believe what they want to believe. but this question is so automatic to people who follows the sports. some Pacquiao hater included.

1. Chatchai Sasakul was a legendary fighter. this win is better than the Genaro Hernandez win as Sasakul was the recognized best fighter of the division.

2. Lehlohono Ledwabba was also the man of the division. He was supposed to steamroll Pacquiao. he was rated that high that people are thinking of inserting him at their p4p list.

3. Marco Antonio Barrera was on big big run before Pacquiao halted him. what did he do after? rack up another run en route to another belt @130. was rated as high as #2 before Pacquio.

4. Juan Manuel Marquez - despite being a stylistic nemesis. Pac was able to beat him twice in 4 tries officially.



Its not Floyds fault but theres no one in his resume that can match the Barrera win.

.......

Pac's
Barrera, Cotto, Sasakul, Hatton, Marquez2X, Ledwabba, Morales, Margarito

Floyds
Castillo, Corales, Hatton, Judah, Mosley, Dela Hoya, Canelo



Pacquiao easily.

[miron_lang]

that's interesting and bait-y that the OP says WINS only counts because it excludes the obvious differentiation in their resumes: the fact that floyd is undefeated and Pac has been KTFO 3 times and lost 5 total. But either way in terms of purely better wins I'd probably have to say Floyd has the better wins at the higher weights and Pac has better wins at the lowest weights (Morales, Barrera, JMM, etc)

Pac muders Floyd at the lower weights
Pac equals Floyd at the higher weights

Pac : Diaz, DLH, Hatton, Cotto, Mosley, Clottey, Margarito, Bradley
Floyd : Baldomir, DLH, Hatton, Cotto, Mosley, Ortiz, Guerrero, Canelo