The new top 10 p4p list

[marvelousmatt]

After Bradley's big win,JMM loss,Rigo's win over Donaire and Danny Garcia's huge win...what is your new top 10 ?

My new Top 10:

1 The Money Man
2 Andre Ward
3 Sergio Martinez
4 Tim Bradley
5 Vlad KO
6 Manny
7 Danny Garcia
8 Carl Froch
9 JMM
10 Canelo Alvarez



On the Cusp :


11 GGG
12 Vitali
13 Adrian Broner
14 The Machine Matthyse
15 Mikey Garcia
16 Donaire
17 Cotto
18 Keith Thurman
19 Leo Santa Cruz
20 Devon Alexander


"One win or one loss does not make a fighter", me.

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

No Rigo? Why is Canelo on there?

[Jloro]

No Bhop? Why is Manny so high?

[King_]

I like Martinez but what do people base their P4P lists on? Nothing against him, but he arguably (should of) lost his last fight and looked absolutely terrible, why do people feel obligated to keep having him so high up on their P4P lists?

It wasn't like the Wlad fight where it was ugly as hell but he still dominated. He looked really, really old. I'd be surprsied if his handlers don't chase a "big money" fight and then cash out.


I wish they would, that's the fight to be made at 160, but I can't see any way Martinez-Golovkin happens unless HBO throws him a ridiculous amount, that would rival the amount he'd make against Cotto, etc.

[Jloro]

I like Martinez but what do people base their P4P lists on? Nothing against him, but he arguably (should of) lost his last fight and looked absolutely terrible, why do people feel obligated to keep having him so high up on their P4P lists?

It wasn't like the Wlad fight where it was ugly as hell but he still dominated. He looked really, really old. I'd be surprsied if his handlers don't chase a "big money" fight and then cash out.


I wish they would, that's the fight to be made at 160, but I can't see any way Martinez-Golovkin happens unless HBO throws him a ridiculous amount, that would rival the amount he'd make against Cotto, etc.

lol but people keep Pac on after being KO'ed and Marquez after he got schooled

[Russian Crushin]

No Wilder? Why is Floyd so high?

[King_]

lol but people keep Pac on after being KO'ed and Marquez after he got schooled

True. I'd say JMM is a more highly regarded opponent then Murray, though. Well Murray is a legit top 10 at 160 but some people had JMM on their P4P lists when he fought Pac.

[Bigg Rigg]

Get Canelo off that list.

[King_]

Get Canelo off that list.

this too, just noticed that

[kurt0411]

Of course pac should be that high, 1 loss in over 10 years were he was the best in the world.