Surely Froch is now P4P Top 5

[The Big Dunn]

you can make a case for froch to be anywhere from 5-8 IMO.

[Jack Napier]

he's got one of the best active resumes right now
don't mind if he gets in the top 5
not sure what Groves means for him individually
but that win adds on to a nice body of work that keeps tallying up

[gmc_rfc_06]

Skill wise Carl doesn't look top 5, but he keeps fighting top level guys and gets the job done in most cases.

Great jab, good power, iron chin, awkwardness, heart/drive, tremendous resume - I have Carl at #7 personally, but I have no issue with #5.

Mayweather, Rigondeaux, Ward....after that, it's wide open now that Sergio is past his best and Marquez is in limbo.

[slimshandy69]

Skill wise Carl doesn't look top 5, but he keeps fighting top level guys and gets the job done in most cases.

Great jab, good power, iron chin, awkwardness, heart/drive, tremendous resume - I have Carl at #7 personally, but I have no issue with #5.

Mayweather, Rigondeaux, Ward....after that, it's wide open now that Sergio is past his best and Marquez is in limbo.

ward doesn't seem legit due to the rumours and hes been to inactive, Rigndeaux, how has he achieved more than froch???

Lets be honest, froch is top 5 without debate.

[low_Bo]

I would be hesitant to put froch in the top 10. It's laughable to consider him top five.

[Rome-By-Ko]

If not top 5,at least top 6..I could see people putting Martinez and Rigo ahead of Froch..For me tho,he's top 5..

[JACK1190]

I definitely have froch top 5 p4p, back to back tough fights, more than deserves it imo.

[RawDawgHasSpokn]

ward doesn't seem legit due to the rumours and hes been to inactive, Rigndeaux, how has he achieved more than froch???

Lets be honest, froch is top 5 without debate.

His whitewashing of Nonito Trumps Frochs entire life story. Kidding, but it was damn impressive.