How would a prime sugar shane do against the current best welters?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Ive always felt a prime mosely beats mayweather in a close fight. mosely was awesome at his best. forrest just had the perfect style to beat him

I agree, shane-floyd would be 50/50 and if a prime shane landed on floyd like he did in 2010,, i dont like floyd's chances,,
and your right about forrest having the best style to beat him,, forrest was very skilled and the funny thing is that he could beat shane and probably ike and oscar, yet its a wild man like mayorga that brought his downfall,,,
styles make fights

[Interloper]

Prime Shane Mosley is capable of being outboxed (see Vernon Forrest). So definitely loses to Mayweather. The problem is, we don't really have any super-talented pure boxers at 140 in this particular generation. It's more boxer/puncher, brawler, slugger, etc.

[NearHypnos]

Prime Shane Mosley is capable of being outboxed (see Vernon Forrest). So definitely loses to Mayweather. The problem is, we don't really have any super-talented pure boxers at 140 in this particular generation. It's more boxer/puncher, brawler, slugger, etc.

So you think a faster stronger Shane lets Floyd escape the 2nd without gassing? >__>... the Shane who used to let his hands go with big combinations and didnt have an Alzheimer's jab? That is a close fight Shane probably has an edge in. Styles make fights.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Prime Shane Mosley is capable of being outboxed (see Vernon Forrest). So definitely loses to Mayweather. The problem is, we don't really have any super-talented pure boxers at 140 in this particular generation. It's more boxer/puncher, brawler, slugger, etc.

floyd and forrest are 2 completely different fighters,,,

I agree that floyd/shane would be a 50/50 fight,,,

but forrest was a tall lanky jabber, that had serious pop,,, floyd would be hard pressed to beat forrest

[tibbar]

The Shane that abused steroids? I'd favor him against a lot of people, he was pretty beastly during his EPO days.

This^^^^^^

[Augustane]

He would be 50/50 with manny and floyd

he would beat the hell out of
alexander
jmm
ghost
ortiz
bradley
and pretty much every other fighter not named floyd and manny

I have to agree here.

[Bushidō]

Mosley is a interesting person in fantasy matchups. He hasn't had too many marquee 147 wins. His best win was vs DLH and probably Margarito.

He would lose to Mayweather and Pacquiao. And would probably be favored vs the rest.

[ELPacman]

Prime Shane constitutes as juiced Shane, no?

[Jc8804]

He would be 50/50 with manny and floyd

he would beat the hell out of
alexander
jmm
ghost
ortiz
bradley
and pretty much every other fighter not named floyd and manny

Shane beats them all

[edgarg]

Prime Shane Mosley is capable of being outboxed (see Vernon Forrest). So definitely loses to Mayweather. The problem is, we don't really have any super-talented pure boxers at 140 in this particular generation. It's more boxer/puncher, brawler, slugger, etc.

Mosley was about 4 " shorter and with a shorter reach. Forrest had very long arms. His left jab won each fight, aided by judicious right crosses whoch would have been lethal for another boxer. it was the first and only time (until MannyP) that Mosley was ever KD-twice in the same early rd. I think the 2nd.