Unbeaten boxers who aren't unbeaten?

[Ghazan]

After Marquez and his team called Tim Bradley the only undefeated boxer with two defeats, which other undefeated boxers do you consider to have been beaten.

Some that I consider not to be undefeated boxers are:

Tim Bradley - Beaten by Pacquiao

Robert Helenuis - Beaten by Derek Chisora

Adrien Broner - Beaten by Daniel Ponce De Leon

Tyson Fury - Beaten by John McDermott

Danny Garcia - Beaten by Ashley Theophane


Who are your choices?

[Outworn]

Floyd Mayweather - Beaten by Jose Luis Castillo.

[New England]

Floyd Mayweather - Beaten by Jose Luis Castillo.

rumor perpetuated by mexicans and dudes who have never seen the fight.


it was a relatively close fight. that's not a robbery.

[Weebler I]

rumor perpetuated by mexicans and dudes who have never seen the fight.

it was a relatively close fight. that's not a robbery.

To be fair he never said it was a robbery, he just said he was beaten. I thought FMJ did enough to win tbh.

[Frank Ducketts]

To be fair he never said it was a robbery, he just said he was beaten. I thought FMJ did enough to win tbh.

To be fair, you didn't even have to clarify his point. We know what the liar said and meant. At least you got it right though. You thought that Floyd clearly beat Castillo.

[Ghazan]

rumor perpetuated by mexicans and dudes who have never seen the fight.


it was a relatively close fight. that's not a robbery.

I recently watched the fight and scored it 114-112 for Mayweather. some could also make a case for 114-112 Castillo. Just one of those fights that could go either way. Similar to how close Marquez vs Pacquiao's first two battles were

[OJ Simpson]

Castillo clearly won the fight. You'd need some ulterior motive to claim otherwise.

[Weebler I]

To be fair, you didn't even have to clarify his point. We know what the liar said and meant. At least you got it right though. You thought that Floyd clearly beat Castillo.

It's an opinion, doesn't make him a liar. See the OP:

which other undefeated boxers do you consider to have been beaten.

A lot of people thought Castillo won. As I said I didn't, but I could see it scored the other way.

[Outworn]

I recently watched the fight and scored it 114-112 for Mayweather. some could also make a case for 114-112 Castillo. Just one of those fights that could go either way. Similar to how close Marquez vs Pacquiao's first two battles were

Enough said.

[Hurtin-Bombs]

You could probably make a case for any fighter that retired undefeated to have an L on their record.

Weird thread