how does the toney who fought holyfield fair against

[bojangles1987]

Beats the first three, losses the last three by decision.

Agreed, except I think the Klitschkos would stop him. Vitali, at least.

EDIT: Okay, Vitali today. Nevermind, decision win.

[Weebler I]

No version of Toney beats Chisora.

[Jc8804]

James beats all of them with ease except wlad and vitali.

Vitali would be tough and stay outside and win on more activity but get hit very clean.

Wlad would win on points and stay outside ,
And be safe as usual. He wouldnt get close enough to be countered by toney.
Toney would be forced to press from the shell
And and wlad would hold to a boring decision in which toney lands few and throws a small number of shots. But toney lands the better shots .
Wlad is just more active outside behind his jab and pawn jab
And he wouldnt land many rt hands on toney.
Size is the issue for toney, if he were 6'2 he would
Beat wlad up

[boliodogs]

Prime Toney doesn't exist at HW even at CW he was flabby.

I know Toney was not in his prime at heavyweight and I think I clearly said so and said he was no bigger than a light heavyweight and grossly overweight fighting as a heavyweight. Still for a 5 ft. 9 inch tub of lard Toney fought very well as a heavyweight and beat the hell out of a washed up Holyfield. Toney was in his prime at 160 and 168. So let me put it this way so there is no misunderstanding. I think a prime Holyfield would easily beat any version of Toney that ever lived whether Toney weighed 160 or 250 or any weight in between and no matter what Toney's age was. Toney was a great fighter for his size but so was Holyfield and Holyfield was so much bigger.