If these fighters were the same weight, who beats the other three?

[KiloTeague]

Who beats the other three? Another way to look at it is, if they all fought 100 fights against each other, who would have the best record?

https://<iframe src="http://epopic.c...="0"></iframe>

[KiloTeague]

Surprise, surprise, I got Roy.

[ImStillHere]

Floyd. Easy pick for me. The only reason people doubt Floyd's ability to beat Leonard/Hearns and such is size. His defence is the best. I have no problem with anyone picking any fighter in this poll, but to say picking one over another is wrong would be ******. You could make good arguments for all four.

[Maffia240]

Roy at welterweight would only look as impressive as Robinson or Leonard but with more power. Mayweather is much smaller than the other 3 so its kinda unfair to put him against these great big boxers that can punch. They basically are a bigger versions of Floyd with more power and slightly less boxing iq.

I pick Robinson cuz he is a better boxer than Roy.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

1. SRR
2. SRL
3. Floyd
4. Roy

SRR was the complete package
SRL was just a winner and would steal rounds vs floyd
floyd is better fundamentally than roy
Roy was great but lack of fundamentals would cause him to lose to the other guys, these guys arent vinny paz, byrd, sosa, hell they are a levels above toney and hopkins, If roy was better fundamentally he would have beaten tarver, forget losing his speed and reflexes, hopkins lost those years ago and schooled tarver, roy should have done the same but he doesnt possess the fundamental skills that a srr, srl, floyd, and hopkins have....

[kardsufur]

SRR:
Offense: 10
Defense: 7
Speed: 8

SRL: Offense 9
Defense: 8
Speed: 9

Floyd:
Offense: 8
Defense: 10
Speed: 9

Roy:
Offense: 10
Defense: 8
Speed: 10

Hard to tell ...

truth is none of them would come on top. I suspect some would beat others while others would beat others and then others would beat the others that beat others...i.e. triangle theory would fail in this one.

SRL might beat Floyd then Floyd would beat SRR then SRR would beat SRL but Jones would beat them all except Floyd, etc

[Bushidō]

Sugar Ray Robinson

[JDezi4]

I might have to be a cliche and pick Robinson... I think Roy's power would be rendered useless by Robinson's chin, and he wasn't as destructive a fighter as he could've been... The lack of fundamentals would hurt once his gifts get negated (especially on the inside)

I think Roy would beat the other 2... Floyd wouldn't be able to handle someone who's lead right hands are not only just as fast, but way more powerful... Leonard would do better, but I think Roy just hits too hard...

I'll concede Roy vs Leonard would be a toss up... IDK

[ImStillHere]

I might have to be a cliche and pick Robinson... I think Roy's power would be rendered useless by Robinson's chin, and he wasn't as destructive a fighter as he could've been... The lack of fundamentals would hurt once his gifts get negated (especially on the inside)

I think Roy would beat the other 2... Floyd wouldn't be able to handle someone who's lead right hands are not only just as fast, but way more powerful... Leonard would do better, but I think Roy just hits too hard...

I'll concede Roy vs Leonard would be a toss up... IDK

Roy more powerful than Floyd? P4P? Don't think so! Who has Roy ever KO'd?

[JDezi4]

Roy more powerful than Floyd? P4P? Don't think so! Who has Roy ever KO'd?

How many people has Floyd left looking ****** on the floor? He has his fair share of bums on his resume even at the lower weights... Bare in mind, we're talking welterweight here