What fighters were not prime or at their peak vs Floyd

[mexicali90]

Every fighter that floyd has ever fought has been either old or not prime. He has nevr beaten anyone worth mentioning. His percieved ATG status and p4p rankings are BS, its based solely on his cherrypicking and avoiding threats. As soon as he fights someone prime he will lose. He only sells ppv because of either the guy he is fighting or the semi main event.

He weigh cheated JMM, fought Hatton at his worst weight, Mosley was old and gassed, cotto was shot, ODH was shot and beat him. He lost to Castillo. Baldomir was slow. Canelo was drained at 152 and too young. He ducked Margs and Pwill as well as prime Kosta, casamayor, johnson, spafadora. He kept putting roadblocks up when manny wanted to fight.

He should fight GGG right now and not Martinez but wont because GGG is a threat. He wont fight outside of Vegas because he can't use xylocaine. He is gay, ellerbee is his boyfriend, and Ms Jackson gets double teamed by 50 and Victor Ortiz everyd

Floyd lies about how much he makes. He'll be broke 2 years after he retires. He beats everyone in fantasy fights.

Ok, did I miss anything. Oh yeah, he testedpositive 3 times but its being covered up by USADA, which floyd controls.

He deserves criticism but geez. he beat cotto at 35, Guerrero at 36, and canelo at damn near 37. But everyone swears hes 25

[The Gambler1981]

He deserves criticism but geez. he beat cotto at 35, Guerrero at 36, and canelo at damn near 37. But everyone swears hes 25

It is the curious case of Floyd Mayweather Jr. he stays the same age while everyone else ages.

[The Gambler1981]

See this is where Floyd hate masks genuine Floyd criticism. This post is exaggerating. Chico always had problems with weight, that didnt stop him from demolishing everyone at 130 except Floyd. Shane wasnt shot to pieces.

If you want to objectively criticize Floyd do it without sounding like a rash hater.

Well you can criticize him he is not above criticism and those questions will be around. The thing is what are you criticizing him compared to, anyone around currently in this era Floyd has done as good or better.

It is a matter of arguing how great he is anyone can debate that, but you can;t debate that he is in fact great

[D4thincarnation]

What fighters did he fight where you felt , this guy isnt the goods
For whatever reason.

Weight, age , injury .

Who ?

Canelo: Too Green

Guererro: Not a true 147lber

Cotto: Past his prime, took heavy punishment in the Margarito and Pacquiao fights. Achieved his goal by getting revenge on Margarito

Ortiz: Maybe just coming into his prime, too stupid though.

Mosley: Way past his prime, ring rusty, over trained and carrying an injury.

Marquez: Was not a welterweight when Floyd fought him, bloated and sluggish with the rapid weight gain.

Hatton: Prime, but was never a force at 147lbs.

Oscar: Well past his prime, 1 fight in the previous 3 years, had problems with alcohol, durgs and cross dressing.

[illmaticfighter]

He deserves criticism but geez. he beat cotto at 35, Guerrero at 36, and canelo at damn near 37. But everyone swears hes 25

lmao, true plus when he fought mosley i believe he was 34 and was a part time fighter. he had only one fight since hatton and that was marquez that's one fight in 3 years.

[JaYDeuce11]

True if younger Mosley would have landed those 2 same shots, it would have been over. BUT Floyd did fight Mosley when everyone had avoided him after that dismantling of a newly=discovered hand wrapped Margarito.
Was gonna say Canelo but who knows how he acts/fights after his first loss. hes only 23 for gods sake, Pacquiao didnt blow up until 29-30s, same with Mayweather to be on top of the world

[bojangles1987]

Mosley
Cotto
Oscar
Marquez
Gatti
Hernandez (Floyd was green though, so it's not like it mattered)

Just thinking of big fights, those struck me immediately.

We'll see about Alvarez. He may or may not have hit his prime yet.

[Fetta]

If i go by NSB standards for floyd then Im sure hes never fought anyone good...ever.

[brick wall]

the thing is if you're going to be honest with this topic, you're just going to be labeled a hater by fanboys and then the thread goes downhill from there.

that's the sad state of nsb right now.