Where does Floyd Mayweather rank among G.O.A.T.?

[J The UnBiased]

He's top 20 for me. I don't even have Duran in my top 10, no way Floyd's there yet. I gotta wait for the book on his career to be closed.

[Poet682006]

#1 its obv, his never lost and faced everyone who wanted him.

So did Marciano but no one's touting him as the GOAT (no one who isn't ******ed at least).

[solo20]

top 50 anybody picking him in 1-10 range DONT KNOW CRAP ABOUT BOXING PERIOD

[kennylimon]

Right now i say Top 20-25. But wait 10 years and you will se Floyd in the Top 10-15 in almost every list.

[DiegoFuego]

The only fighters I have ever seen that I think are better than Floyd are Sugar Ray Robinson and Muhammad Ali.

[Zano-24]

He is probably in the top 10-15 right now but 10-15 years from now he will be in the top 5 most likely.

[BIGBOXINGFAN]

Listen.......When someone ask me for my opinion then it's my f----ing opinion.
And in my opinion he is top 3.

On My list......again folks it's my damn list.

If you have a problem with it.....oh well

[BIGBOXINGFAN]

Right now i say Top 20-25. But wait 10 years and you will se Floyd in the Top 10-15 in almost every list.

I respect your opinion.....but can you name me 20-25 guys who are more talented overall than Floyd. As a matter of fact name me 10. I'll wait

[Digital Hu$tler]

Top 3 Robinson Ali Mayweather

[Ray Corso]

Around 50th looks right to me!! My reasons are easy to understand, he's not an offensive fighter and doesn't look to finish a fight! His excellant defense would not be that excellant against some of the welters who could punch much harder than ANYONE he's fought! Floyd is very talented but as a welter he's small, has light hands and is becoming more and more one dimentional.

Some folks need to think about all the great fighters from ALL the weight classes! From 140 to 154 where Floyd operates from heres a few that he would need to be "perfect" with or get beat up badly or KO'd!

some of the more modern guys;
Pete Whitaker
Don Curry
...................
Ray Leonard
Tommy Hearns
................
Jose Napoles
Emile Griffth
..................
Barney Ross
Sugar Ray
................
Henry Armstrong
Mickey Walker...................heres a few men from different era's that in my opionion could handle Floyd without to much trouble. The problem would be chasing him down and making him fight!

Maybe Floyd should move up to Middleweight and fight that Champ. Floyd says he's better than Sugar Ray, Sugar moved up to fight LaMotta as a welter and beat him. Sergio isn't exactly fighting amotta so why not try?

If your tha great or the greatest! I think being the best of your geneation should be just fine, and a great accomplishment too! Some fans just get carried away at times, its those fan-at-ics! Top fifty is pretty damn good!!
Ray