New Pound for Pound Rankings (The Ring and TBRB)

[Sugar Adam Ali]

The fan in me is tempted to put Rigo in the top 5 but I can understand with only 12 fights and one meaningful W.

I feel the same way, but i just think that rigo schooled a top 5 p4p guy and it wasnt even close,,, it looked like mayweather-ghost in there,,,,

Rigo may have only 12 fights, but i would be hard pressed to name fighters that beat him H2H

And when it comes down to it i think he beats everyone not named floyd, ward is higher because of the better resume, but rigo chopping at his heels...

for the record i have
1. floyd
2. ward
3. rigo
4. jmm
5. manny
6. bradley
7. wlad
8. froch
9. gonzales
10. mikey Garcia

with honorable mentions to: serg donaire ggg canelo broner lucas danny

[HanzGruber]

Actually surprised Rigo made it lol. And I guarantee if cAnelo loses the Danny Lucas winner will be on there next

[LoadedWraps]

TBRB

Mayweather
Ward
Marquez
Martinez
Pacquiao
Froch
Klitschko
Rigondeaux
Donaire
R. Gonzalez

The Ring

Mayweather
Ward
Marquez
Klitschko
Martinez
Pacquiao
Broner
Bradley
Alvarez
Rigondeaux


Good to see Chocolito finally getting some recognition. The Ring ratings are still ****ty but at least they finally gave Rigo his well deserved spot in the top 10.

I disagree with both lists, but I have seen much, much worse. (i.e., on NSB)
Basically I won't complain about either list, but mine would look differently. And no, I am not posting mine to be discussed about right now.

[GRboxing]

Pacquiao has gone 1-2 in his last 3. Why is he still on?

Rigondeaux needs to be higher, and I have no doubt he'll get screwed over for Matthysse when/if Matthysse clubs Garcia to Bolivia and enters the list.

Not the worst lists I've seen though

[mathed]

ESPN P4P

1. Mayweather
2. Ward
3. JMM
4. Pac
5. Martinez
6. Rigo
7. Wlad
8. Donaire
9. Bradley
10. Froch

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Pacquiao has gone 1-2 in his last 3. Why is he still on?

Rigondeaux needs to be higher, and I have no doubt he'll get screwed over for Matthysse when/if Matthysse clubs Garcia to Bolivia and enters the list.

Not the worst lists I've seen though

manny still on because he was the legit #2 guy behind floyd, maybe slipped to 3 after jmm3 and ward winning super6...

everyone knows he beat bradley so i dont hold that against him,,

and the jmm4 fight was super exciting and manny looked great til he went to dreamland,, and jmm was another p4p guy, so i just kinda switched spots with them,,,
I still think manny is better than 95% of the fighters out there,,,,
unlike donaire and serg who got beat up by guys not considered p4p, even though rigo is now a p4p guy

but im done for the night,,, have a goodnight y'all

[GRboxing]

manny still on because he was the legit #2 guy behind floyd, maybe slipped to 3 after jmm3 and ward winning super6...

everyone knows he beat bradley so i dont hold that against him,,

and the jmm4 fight was super exciting and manny looked great til he went to dreamland,, and jmm was another p4p guy, so i just kinda switched spots with them,,,
I still think manny is better than 95% of the fighters out there,,,,
unlike donaire and serg who got beat up by guys not considered p4p, even though rigo is now a p4p guy

but im done for the night,,, have a goodnight y'all

Yeah but you can't be P4P and lose and then get sparked out and still have a spot IMO plus his fight with Rios isn't exactly P4P worthy. Manny was the big favorite and he got sparked and got a gift.

For instance Roy Jones was dropped straight to #10 when he got sparked by Tarver and he was #1 P4P for the longest time.

[New England]

froch over klitschko?



froch was absolutely dominated by ward, a man of his size. i have no issues with froch being in the top 10, but to have him over wladimir klitschko, perhaps the most dominant fighter in the sport, is insane.

[Joey_Torreo]

Can't get over broner being on there, Alvarez too. But other than that the rings isn't that bad they got rigo in there. Oh and frog should be in there too

[Mr. Fantastic]

Ward is too high plus he hasn't fought in almost a year. The guys putting in work should get more credit than dudes sitting back. Take him off or at least he should be placed lower.

Broner needs to be taken off and put Froch in there. Rigo should be put higher.