Clearest victory over Malignaggi - Khan, Cotto, Hatton, Diaz or Broner?

[teddycanyon]

Khan embarrassed Malignaggi,by beating him at his own game. I consider that the best win over Malignaggi and one of the better victories in Khan's career.

[edgarg]

According to official judges scorecards it's Amir Khan since he won every round on all judges scorecards until eventually stopping Paulie in 11th. Hatton won all rounds except one on all judges scorecards, stopped Paulie in 11, and for Cotto, Broner and Diaz the fights were considered to be much closer by some of the judges.

If you've seen all those fights who do you think beat Malignaggi most clearly?

I've seen all the fights except Broner's and I believe that Hatton gave Malignaggi the worst beating. Khan and Cotto won well, but they were far more competitive whereas with Hatton, it was clear from the very first round that he had no chance and that Hatton was walking right through his punches. He had no way even to box him or keep him away because Hatton was pretty fast on his feet as well.

[sugarsmosley]

Paulie was dominated by Cotto, Khan, and Hatton. Cotto and Khan are tied for me.

[Chrismart]

I'd say Khan.

[boliodogs]

It was Khan for sure. Khan won every round with ease. None of the others did that.

[al-Xander]

Broner young doe. Not ready for prime time yet.

[messenger]

I think Cotto and Hatton put the biggest beating on Paulie. Broner barely beat him.

[Jam Jars]

LOL @ those that voted Cotto, even if that was the "best" Malignaggi he didn't get the clearest victory, not even close.

[Cardinal Buck]

That might've been Hatton's career best performance along with the Castillo fight.

[daggum]

LOL @ those that voted Cotto, even if that was the "best" Malignaggi he didn't get the clearest victory, not even close.

why would that be the best malignaggi? because he was undefeated lol! he also fought nothing but bums before fighting cotto. he got all his good experience after the cotto fight.