If we take out Floyd, JMM and Pac out the picture, who holds the welter throne?

[HanzGruber]

Prob Tim. I don't think anyone them would be undefeated out of that list thought cause khan is a terrible match up for Tim and ghost.

[SplitSecond]

guerrero?.........

made this post before the poll
there's a question mark because i wasn't sure, i felt i was leaving someone out

now with the poll out yea, it was bradley i was forgetting, but still, although he'd put up a good fight against the ghost, i'd bank on guerrero winning that fight, bradley's defense is non-existent agains southpaws, robert is stronger, as good stamina and his punches will be more noticeable, he can also mix it up on the inside, so although it could be a close fight, if anyone is to be manhandled, it will definitely not be guerrero, too big too strong

so my initial post stands, i think guerrero the best after "The Three Inimigos"

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Keith one time Thurman

Yeah, thats my dude,,, super exciting, not sure how far he will go, but def one to watch....


I would say bradley would be #1 if no jmm manny or floyd..

but honestly the division would be wide open and i could see there being no dominant champ,

Cotto could beat all these guys if he ever trained hard and made 147,, Im sick of seeing him with love handles...

[$Bullsfam$]

Cotto comes back down and is Undisputed champ

[malcolm]

Floyd gets no credit because he dodged to many good fights! Simple as that.
Deal with it Flowmos

Don't be mad at Floyd because Antonio Margarito's boxing career has been WIPED OUT b/c of his usage of ILLEGAL hand wraps.

I bet the haters wanted Floyd to fight him with the illegal wraps. LOL!

You guys are pathetic.

[Pr23]

Cotto if he trained hard n got to 147 he'd be the best there

[malcolm]

Cotto if he trained hard n got to 147 he'd be the best there

I don't think Cotto can beat Guerrero at 147.

Cotto almost was ko'd a few times at 140.

[SERVILEV]

Yep i choose clottey! The same clottey that went to war w cotto. Clottey is a big strong WW whom was looking good up til pacq. No one on this list has the ability to overwhelm him like paqc did. Imo

[Pr23]

I don't think Cotto can beat Guerrero at 147.

Cotto almost was ko'd a few times at 140.

Because he couldn't make weight healthy at 140 he was drained n chinny at that weight. At 147 his chin was way better. The only time he got knockdown at 147 other than taking a knee due to plaster was pacquiao. I think it be a good fight but he's better than Guerrero

[ROSS CALIFORNIA]

Broner of course.