Who would you rate higher P4P, GGG or Lucas Matthysse?

[WarMaidana]

I think GGG is probably more unstoppable than Lucas Matthysse is, but there is no question Matthysse has a better resume. Matthysse is 34-2 (32 KOs) while Golovkin is 27-0 (24 KOs). Matthysse has wins over Lamont Peterson, Humberto Soto, Ajose Olusegun, Demarcus Corley, Mioke Dallas Jr and probably should have wins against Zab Judah and Devon Alexander but he got robbed. GGG has wins over Matt Macklin, Ishida, Rosado, Proska and Ouma.

Both guys are animals, KO machines, beasts, and produce highlight reel knockouts. I believe GGG is even better than Matthysse but Matthysse has a better resume, so the question is HYPOTHETICALLY if you had to and could only move one guy in top 10 P4P ratings who would it be?

Ps. We all know ring magazines ratings are a joke... no way should Broner and Alvarez be in there.

[ИATAS]

Lucas has the better resume no questions about that but I think GGG is more skilled imo.

[Russian Crushin]

I saw this exact thread on boxing asylum lol

Currently it's def Lucas, he has the better wins which is 95% of proving who's better, but I think Golovkin is the better fighters with more upside

[bojangles1987]

Matthysse would deserve a p4p spot before Golovkin, though I think Golovkin is better.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I will lean towards GGG just for the simple fact that he has a great amateur background and seems to have a more polished skill set.....

Lucas is a monster but he sorta in the margarito/mayorga/maidana/pavlik/froch skill club
while GGG in my opinion is more on the level of tsyzu/curry/tito level

Just my opinion...

Truthfully though Lucas has fought the far better competition but i still think GGG slightly ahead p4p skill wise

[deuce_drop]

gotta go with Lucas because of the quality of opponents, but as soon as GGG gets some better names, it's dead even until one of them does something outrageous.


I like both fighters, they're great for boxing, and give nothing but entertaining fights....

[vacon04]

Lucas by far. He has beaten Peterson, Dallas Jr, Olusegun and Soto and IMO he clearly beat Alexander and Judah too.

[kedashy]

lucas of course... he have stepped in the ring with some known fighters and have knocked everyone of them down and some out...

[Em1]

Is this a real question? GGG is fighting tomato cans that HBO is using to make their next star since they have no Golden Boy fighters.

[Rome-By-Ko]

I'm going to have to go with Lucas,he's fought the higher ranked fighter..They are both beast tho..