Gennady Golovkin should be in the top ten P4P

[Light_Speed]

Talent wise he should be on it, but I think he needs to beat a top 5 guy in his weightclass before being a certified P4P fighter.

[The Hammer]

[chav]

based on potential? maybe. but he shouldnt be on any real list. he doesnt have nearly the resume to justify it.

Who do you rate higher, Broner or GGG?

You are always very active in GGG threads, so im keen to hear your reply on this one. thanks

[dc3383]

No for now if he 's beat Sergio or even Chavez Jr then sure

[hhs661]

I've seen people make claims for Canelo, Mikey Garcia and Bradley on here. Yet none of those guys have impressed the way GGG did tonight. He may be teetering around the top ten, but not quite there yet. Damn close though.

This guy has the potential to be a long stay in the top 3 p4p rankings, IMO

[SCtrojansbaby]

Every indication is he will be top 10, heck top 3 P4P very soon but right now he's not even top 20. P4P is about resume not how good you are.

[Kagami Taiga]

Who do you rate higher, Broner or GGG?

You are always very active in GGG threads, so im keen to hear your reply on this one. thanks

rate higher as in what? neither are p4p broner has the much better resume. golovkin seems much more polished but he is also a lot older so broner certainly has more potential.

[DoktorSleepless]

His best win is Macklin. NO.

[BafanaBafana]

I am also not completely sold on Golovkin as a fighter by the way. He did what he was supposed to do, impressively might I add, but I don't know how he'd fare against a fighter who would shut his angles down. It's hard to think of many fighters who would problem him in the middleweight division today, but that's because the division is lacking in talent. At the same time it feels means not rating a fighter highly because Bernard and Hagler would dispatch of them. I suppose what I mean to say is he's somewhere between good and great, I just don't know the exact position.

What do you mean the division is lacking in talent? No **** the division seems lacking in talent when you compare the current crop to 2 top 15 ATG's.

There's actually a lot of depth in this division:

1. • Sergio Martinez (RING, WBC middleweight champion)
2. • Gennedy Golovkin (WBA middleweight champion)
3. • Daniel Geale (IBF middleweight champion)
4. • Peter Quillin (WBO middleweight champion)
5. • Julio Cesar Chavez Jr
6. • Martin Murray
7. • Mathew Macklin
8. • Hassan N'Dam N'Jikam
9. • Felix Sturm
10. • Darren Barker
11. • Dmitry Pirog
12. • Sergio Mora
13. • Brian Vera
14. • Marco Antonio Rubio
15. • Andy Lee
16. • Max Bursak
17. • Grzegorz Proksa
18. • Osumanu Adama
19. • Danny Jacobs
20. • David Lemieux

You can't find many other divisions in boxing with that kind of depth in the top 20.

[mobstarik]

GGG about perfect punch: "That was my present to Mackin"