Closest fight/robbery: Malignaggi-Broner, Martinez-Murray, Love-Rosado?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • F!x
    It's In!
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jan 2013
    • 2066
    • 124
    • 40
    • 38,324

    #1

    Closest fight/robbery: Malignaggi-Broner, Martinez-Murray, Love-Rosado?

    Just out of those 3 recent fights, what do you think was the worst robbery and/or the closest fight which either fighter could be given the W?

    Paulie Malignaggi vs Adrien Broner
    Sergio Martinez vs Martin Murray
    J'Leon Love vs Gabriel Rosado
    43
    [Closest fight] Paulie Malignaggi vs Adrien Broner
    11.63%
    5
    [Closest fight] Sergio Martinez vs Martin Murray
    25.58%
    11
    [Closest fight] J'Leon Love vs Gabriel Rosado
    9.30%
    4
    [Worst robbery] Paulie Malignaggi vs Adrien Broner
    9.30%
    4
    [Worst robbery] Sergio Martinez vs Martin Murray
    11.63%
    5
    [Worst robbery] J'Leon Love vs Gabriel Rosado
    27.91%
    12
    No fight was close
    0.00%
    0
    No fight was a robbery
    4.65%
    2
    Other
    0.00%
    0
  • Dirk Diggler UK
    Deleted
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Jun 2008
    • 48836
    • 1,312
    • 693
    • 58,902

    #2
    Martin Murray vs Martinez was the worst decision out of those. Murray pretty much outboxed Martinez all night and knocked him down twice but still didn't get the verdict.

    Next would be Rosdado vs Love.

    Paulie vs Broner wasn't a robbery or even a bad decision. It was a lot closer than I expected though.

    Comment

    • thuggery
      proper rock slanga'
      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
      • Jan 2012
      • 10309
      • 717
      • 1,342
      • 18,054

      #3
      1. Malignaggi-Broner *robbery
      2. Love-Rosado *robbery
      3. Martinez-Murray *could have gone either way

      Comment

      • Rome-By-Ko
        The winner Is
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Mar 2009
        • 20157
        • 323
        • 332
        • 29,833

        #4
        I did not think any of these fights could be consider a robbery tbh..They were all close fights imo..I had Rosado beating Love,and Murray beating Martinez..Not by a lot tho,very close fights..I thought Broner Paulie M was close but a clear win for Broner imo..

        Comment

        • BornToLive
          Interim Champion
          Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
          • Apr 2012
          • 604
          • 55
          • 0
          • 6,874

          #5
          I'm not even a fan of Broner but he won comfortable, 8-4.

          First 4 rounds i had Paulie 3-1 up & the next round i have him was the 10th.

          Martinez vs Murray was close but i scored it Martinez, think by 1 point & Love-Rosado was close as well & i scored it for Rosado.


          Comment

          • gmc_rfc_06
            Undisputed Champion
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Oct 2010
            • 9486
            • 282
            • 131
            • 16,947

            #6
            Murray-Martinez was the closest, I can understand those who scored it either way.

            Comment

            • Rip Chudd
              1 John 2:22
              Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
              • Jun 2010
              • 22689
              • 1,932
              • 1,321
              • 260,351

              #7
              Originally posted by BornToLive
              I'm not even a fan of Broner but he won comfortable, 8-4.

              First 4 rounds i had Paulie 3-1 up & the next round i have him was the 10th.

              Martinez vs Murray was close but i scored it Martinez, think by 1 point & Love-Rosado was close as well & i scored it for Rosado.


              I had the Malignaggi fight scored the exact same way

              Comment

              • M Bison
                Perfect, but you're not
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • Mar 2012
                • 15677
                • 600
                • 798
                • 32,424

                #8
                Originally posted by thuggery
                1. Malignaggi-Broner *robbery
                2. Love-Rosado *robbery
                3. Martinez-Murray *could have gone either way
                Agreed with that, share same thoughts!

                Rosado got robbed because he was fighting against Mayweathers puppet.

                Broner got the nod for the complete obvious reason that he is Broner he is supported by crooked guys in boxing and he is hyped up to be the next big thing plus he generates a bit of money.
                Watching the post fight press was the most shoddiest thing I've ever seen, try and sell the hype after their fighter clearly didn't do enough.

                The funny thing being If the shoe was on the other foot and It was Malignaggi looking to counter punch and Broner looking to throw with sheer volume...
                People would then be talking about how he won by work-rate, controlled the fight, made the fight and was clearly the guy who fought like he wanted to earn that title... but no the guy who was more focused on posing up for the camera and shrugging his shoulders got the nod, this is boxing for you If you're a prospect they will do anything to protect you.

                Hypocrites, simple as that.
                Last edited by M Bison; 06-29-2013, 06:26 AM.

                Comment

                • marvelousmatt
                  Interim Champion
                  Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
                  • Feb 2013
                  • 901
                  • 30
                  • 61
                  • 7,099

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Keitha313
                  Agreed with that, share same thoughts!

                  Rosado got robbed because he was fighting against Mayweathers puppet.

                  Broner got the nod for the complete obvious reason that he is Broner he is supported by crooked guys in boxing and he is hyped up to be the next big thing plus he generates a bit of money.
                  Watching the post fight press was the most shoddiest thing I've ever seen, try and sell the hype after their fighter clearly didn't do enough.

                  The funny thing being If the shoe was on the other foot and It was Malignaggi looking to counter punch and Broner looking to throw with sheer volume...
                  People would then be talking about how he won by work-rate, controlled the fight, made the fight and was clearly the guy who fought like he wanted to earn that title... but no the guy who was more focused on posing up for the camera and shrugging his shoulders got the nod, this is boxing for you If you're a prospect they will do anything to protect you.

                  Hypocrites, simple as that.
                  Broner beat Paulie in a close fight,period 7-5.

                  Sergio barely beat Murray(the other KD that was not scored was the difference in the fight) without it...Sergio 7-5.

                  Rosado won 6 rounds vs Love and had a 10-8 round to boot .Love looked awful and cheated to make weight.That was a horrible decision.

                  Comment

                  • marvelousmatt
                    Interim Champion
                    Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
                    • Feb 2013
                    • 901
                    • 30
                    • 61
                    • 7,099

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Dirk Diggler UK
                    Martin Murray vs Martinez was the worst decision out of those. Murray pretty much outboxed Martinez all night and knocked him down twice but still didn't get the verdict.

                    Next would be Rosdado vs Love.

                    Paulie vs Broner wasn't a robbery or even a bad decision. It was a lot closer than I expected though.
                    The other KD was not scored in that Sergio fight and won the fight for him .7-5.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP