Comments Thread For: Malignaggi: Broner Not That Good, Not Good For Boxing

[-DSG-]

paulie is still crying because he lost. give paulie all respect for what he accomplished in his career. but frankly he lost to a guy that didn't even look that good.

Who did you have winning trout-Canelo?

[HanzGruber]

There is evidence, he knows that judge was appointed by Haymon and he was 100% right. Paulie knows the game and calls it like it is. Jim Grey needs to be punched in the ***in mouth.

There's evidence? Where. Paulie is just butthurt. Remember the one judge for trout cAnelo who only have trout like 2 or 3 rounds. That's way worse than paulies score. And trout is with haymon.

[Weebler I]

There's evidence? Where. Paulie is just butthurt. Remember the one judge for trout cAnelo who only have trout like 2 or 3 rounds. That's way worse than paulies score. And trout is with haymon.

Trout did get dropped and hurt though. He wasn't that far from getting stopped. It was in his opponent's backyard too. PM wasn't dropped, wasn't hurt and was fighting at home.

Trout hit the jackpot with Haymon getting the Cotto and Canelo fights in first place. He did well for him.

[The Big Dunn]

Who did you have winning trout-Canelo?

Canelo-with he caveat that the open scoring made trout change the way he was fighting. I thought the score when announced was ridiculously wide.

[HanzGruber]

Trout did get dropped and hurt though. He wasn't that far from getting stopped. It was in his opponent's backyard too. PM wasn't dropped, wasn't hurt and was fighting at home.

Trout hit the jackpot with Haymon getting the Cotto and Canelo fights in first place. He did well for him.

Yea but there's no reason to think ab-paulie was fixed. Steve farhood gave ab 116. Does that mean he's in haymons pocket too?

[The Big Dunn]

Yea but there's no reason to think ab-paulie was fixed. Steve farhood gave ab 116. Does that mean he's in haymons pocket too?

I had it 116-112. Tthat said, it can be argued the judge that had it 117-111 is just as bad as the judge that had paulie winning 115-113. More ringside writers had the fight closer to the 117-111 score.

I thought 117-111 was too wide but paulie surely didn't win.

[-DSG-]

Canelo-with he caveat that the open scoring made trout change the way he was fighting. I thought the score when announced was ridiculously wide.

You didn't find trout-nelo and Paulie-broner to be very similar I thought both trout and malignaggi deserved the nod.

[Weebler I]

Yea but there's no reason to think ab-paulie was fixed. Steve farhood gave ab 116. Does that mean he's in haymons pocket too?

I'm not saying it was fixed, but Schreck was the New York judge, Paulie was a New York fighter fighting in NY but he slaughtered him with that card in favour of the guy from Cinncinati. Maybe he saw it that way, but it's unusual for a home judge to do it like that.

[The Big Dunn]

You didn't find trout-nelo and Paulie-broner to be very similar I thought both trout and malignaggi deserved the nod.

Not really. Canelo benefitted from the open scoring but yeah that one scorecard was crazy. Paulie was punching but broner blocked alot and landed more shots. I wasn't as alarmed by the 117-11 score but I did think it was too much.

[P-4-P-King]

Broner is exposeeedd, Paulie speaking truth.