Broner vs. Judah makes the most sense!

[El Angel]

Canelo is the same age.



He's fighting a guy named Floyd Mayweather next....

[malcolm]

Canelo is the same age.



He's fighting a guy named Floyd Mayweather next....

Canelo is the same age but he has like 20 more pro fights than Broner.

Who was Canelo fighting in his 27th fight??

[El Angel]

Gotta love how Zab loses AGAIN, and is already being talked about for Garcia and Alvarado. Broner should fight Maidana next, Judah is step back against a JWW when he just won a WW title.

[malcolm]

So total fights don't mean anything? Tell me who Canelo was fighting in his 27th pro fight. Now match that guy against Paulie Malinaggi.

Think before you **** ride the next man's post..

[malcolm]

Gotta love how Zab loses AGAIN, and is already being talked about for Garcia and Alvarado. Broner should fight Maidana next, Judah is step back against a JWW when he just won a WW title.

Zab beat the "NSB ALL TIME LEGEND" Lucas Matthyse. That should earn him lifetime props on this forum.

On this forum it goes:

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Muhammed Ali
3. Lucas Matthyse

[kiaba360]

What did Shane Mosley or Joseito Lopez do to earn a shot at Canelo?

Nothing.

But it's okat b/c Canelo was still green and looking to gain experience.

The same path should be used for Broner. People just want to see Broner destroyed ASAP.

No, Canelo fighting Mosley/Lopez was NOT alright. But seeing as how young "stars" have been fighting past-prime/faded opponents for the longest, I guess we have to just accept such a bullshit match-up. I'm tired of old fighters with names getting recycled to be used as stepping stones.

[El Angel]

So total fights don't mean anything? Tell me who Canelo was fighting in his 27th pro fight. Now match that guy against Paulie Malinaggi.

Think before you **** ride the next man's post..

Amateurs mean nothing? Canelo had 20 total amateur fights, Broner went 300-19. That counts for something, Canelo learned as pro, Broner fine tuned. Big difference.

Zab beat the "NSB ALL TIME LEGEND" Lucas Matthyse. That should earn him lifetime props on this forum.

On this forum it goes:

1. Sugar Ray Robinson
2. Muhammed Ali
3. Lucas Matthyse

Beat Matthysse? He got a gift. Why shouldn't Broner fight a WW? He just fought a tiny WW with no punch, it's time to take some risk.

[Chiboxing123]

Honestly a rematch with Reese makes the most sense after this sh// lol

[r__mutt]

Honestly a rematch with Reese makes the most sense after this sh// lol

Ahah! Wouldn't even be surprised if that happened...or a rematch with Ponce but Broner gets to come in at 147.

[malcolm]

Amateurs mean nothing? Canelo had 20 total amateur fights, Broner went 300-19. That counts for something, Canelo learned as pro, Broner fine tuned. Big difference.



Beat Matthysse? He got a gift. Why shouldn't Broner fight a WW? He just fought a tiny WW with no punch, it's time to take some risk.

You make a small point with the amateur arguement; however, it is null and void when you take into consideration the vast difference between amateur boxing and pro boxing.

No head gear. Glove size. Different point system. Age difference of boxers.

So like I said, who was Canelo fighting in his 27th pro fight? Now compare that guy to Paulie Malinaggi.

And regarding Broner fighting a JWW... his last fight before tonite was at 135. Tonite was the first time the kid went 12 rounds. Why throw him to the sharks already?

It took Canelo 50 something pro fights to be considered ready to fight a 36 year old Floyd Mayweather. Some still feel Canelo is too green.