Should HBO Replace Max Kellerman for Ellie Seckbach

[noStylez]

No thanks,

A lot of ppl give Seckbach crap but I like the guy he gives us insight to what otherwise would be unseen. He consistently gets interviews and goes in and around other gyms.
He's good for boxing but I wouldn't have him as a commentator.

[TBear]

Max is ok. He's no Merchant but maybe in time.


I would take him over Showtime's Malignaggi personally. Malignaggi would be ok if they didn't make him inhale helium before each show.

[FlatLine]

Lol.. Seckbach? No way. He just doesn't have the same knowledge as Max.

If you're going to choose a YouTuber to replace Kellerman it would have to be Dwyer because his overall boxing knowledge is far greater than Ellie's and he is actually more articulate and eloquent than Kellerman .

I like Seckbach's dedication to the sport but he belongs on Youtube.

[Lords]

Close this idiotic thread. Ellie has no clue about boxing.

[Capaedia]

lol he'd be the worst commentator ever.

That honour would still belong to Ferdie Pacheco


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[WesleySnipes]

oh god this guy cant be serious...

[raskat]

I think Seckbach is not as knowledgeable as Kellerman boxing wise. BUT: Seckbach should be hired by HBO for doing interviews because nobody and I mean NOBODY has done more for boxing when it comes to reporting than Seckbach.
Seckbach goes from gym to gym to pick up the unfiltered stories we all want to hear. Man, I watched probably thousands of Seckbach's vids in the last 5 years or so.

[Jack Napier]

why the hell would they do that?
they groomed Max for yrs to eventually replace Merchant
he's filling the role well enough, and he's knowledgeable
after losing Larry and the death of Steward, why swap Max?

[JmH Reborn]

I'd take pure silence over anyone

[D-MiZe]

HBO would go down the shitter if they hired Ellie Setback.