Who won Martinez vs Murray?

[DoktorSleepless]

I didn't score it round by round, but I felt that Murray Edged it. Poll coming

[Levity]

It was a very close fight.

I had Martinez winning 114-113.

[puga]

8-4 murray ... plus , 2 kd's should've been scored for murray ... competitive but clear win for murray imo...

[-Kev-]

114-112 Murray.

[-Kev-]

Those who scored it for Martinez, please state who you had winning Canelo-Trout.

[Levity]

I had Canelo-Trout a draw, but the fights aren't perfectly comparable.

Murray didn't start doing much until the fourth, while Canelo was already landing consistently well by the second. Murray's effective work was largely concentrated in rounds 6-10, while Canelo was relatively effective in a greater range and number of rounds.

[Hyper Knuckles]

I look up to and respect Martinez immensely as the skilled athlete he is but I think Murray squeezed it out. I also think Canelo legitimately beat Trout....

[JaguaresMx]

Those who scored it for Martinez, please state who you had winning Canelo-Trout.

why does that matter?

114-113 Sergio

[-Kev-]

I had Canelo-Trout a draw, but the fights aren't perfectly comparable.

Murray didn't start doing much until the fourth, while Canelo was already landing consistently well by the second. Murray's effective work was largely concentrated in rounds 6-10, while Canelo was relatively effective in a greater range and number of rounds.

Based on clean punching, both Murray and Canelo won.

I can not give it to Trout because of his ineffective activity with jabs and I can not give it to Martinez because of his...well nothing, he didn't out land, out throw, or landed cleaner punches than Murray.

Based on who landed the better punches, the more eye opening, effective, clean punching, Murray won. Martinez won the showboating contest for sure.

[Levity]

why does that matter?

114-113 Sergio

Because he's making the reductive argument that if you had Canelo winning due to effective punching, you must also have Murray winning for the same reason.