So Canelo on the p4p list yet?

[285Kid]

When Floyd beats Guerrero you know ring magazine will put Canelo in there

[4Corners]

When Floyd beats Guerrero you know ring magazine will put Canelo in there

I'm a big Broner fan, and Canelo is pretty good, but how in the wide world of sports is Rigondeaux not on the P4P list for beating Donaire, who was #5.....but Donaire still keeps a spot??? That is asinine.

[AgainstTheRopes]

No, he didnt even win yesterday's fight on my scorecard. So why would he?

[Rudiamonds]

The list goes

Mayweather
Ward
Martinez
JMM
Rigo
Wlad
Bradley
Mares
Froch
Canelo

I bet the same people talking down on Canelo got Manny and Donaire in their garbage top 10.

The fact that you don't have PAC on the list at all make your list uncredited let be real

[285Kid]

I'm a big Broner fan, and Canelo is pretty good, but how in the wide world of sports is Rigondeaux not on the P4P list for beating Donaire, who was #5.....but Donaire still keeps a spot??? That is asinine.

When Floyd beats Guerrero , both Donaire and Guerrero will be out of the list

The top 10 will change after May 4 (Flord/Guerrero) , and again on after May 25 (Froch/Kessler).

[-DSG-]

well they put Broner on for beating Demarco

Trout > Broner's entire resume combined

Broner destroyed the number one lightweight try again.

[HeroBando]

does he partake in making the rankings? if so that explain a whole lot. this man scored calzaghe-hopkins 9 rounds to 3 for calzaghe. how could he be wrong?

That's the guy. Here's one Ring editor washing his hands of their rankings:

http://******. craveonline.com/blog/...friday-mailbag

Everyone on the Ratings Panel agrees that Broner is rated too high on the P4P list and that he shouldn’t be ahead of Donaire. Don’t blame them for the new pound-for-pound rankings. They had no input. Ring editor Michael Rosenthal and I did, but obviously, our opinions fell on deaf ears. The pound-for-pound rankings as it is now is just Chuck Giampa’s list.

[CaneloMaidana]

The fact that you don't have PAC on the list at all make your list uncredited let be real

Yeah the guy who just got knocked out and is fighting Alvarado is clearly p4p, you Pacquiao fans love it both ways.

[HeroBando]

Yeah the guy who just got knocked out and is fighting Alvarado is clearly p4p, you Pacquiao fans love it both ways.

He was top 2 already, and lost in a competitive fight vs another p4per, who happens to be his toughest matchup. Before that he beat another p4per, which is a very good result despite the scorecards. Alvarado is no worse than Guerrero h2h and Pac is coming off a bad KO, not sure why the complaining.

[CaneloMaidana]

He was top 2 already, and lost in a competitive fight vs another p4per, who happens to be his toughest matchup. Before that he beat another p4per, which is a very good result despite the scorecards. Alvarado is no worse than Guerrero h2h and Pac is coming off a bad KO, not sure why the complaining.

You don't count Bradley as a loss but you count JMM-Pacquiao 3 as a win, so I know you are biased, Alvarado is a 140 pounder, you Pacquiao fans are every bit as bad as Mayweather fans.