Garcia not on p4p list

[BafanaBafana]

Carl Froch 8-2 vs these guys he should be on the list

Yusaf Mack
Lucian Bute
Andre Ward
Glen Johnson
Arthur Abraham
Mikkel Kessler
Andre Dirrell
Jermain Taylor
Jean Pascal
Albert Rybacki

I never understood why people highlight losses (particularly pertaining Carl Froch) as if they increased P4P status, ridiculous.

Yusaf Mack (lol)
Lucian Bute (glass chinned hype job w/no notable wins)
Andre Ward (LOSS)
Glen Johnson (shot hard-chinned old man w/a thousand losses)
Arthur Abraham (middleweight orangutan)
Mikkel Kessler (LOSS)
Andre Dirrell (LOSS/robbery win)
Jermain Taylor (shot middleweight, almost lost wide)
Jean Pascal (green)
Albert Ryback (who?)

Maybe at #9/10 tops, but he certainly deserves to be there over a lot of people on the Ring list (namely Broner & Guerrero).

[LeG00N]

Garcia, Bradley and Broner over Vilora and Froch

[mathed]

The best names on Garcia's record are Morales, Khan, Holt and Campbell. Morales and Campbell are but a shell of themselves and have been for the past 2 years or so and Holt has been on the slide as well.

So basically, his resume is Khan. This is the guy who has been KTFO twice, lost to Peterson, ducked rematches with all the guys that beat him and just fought a lightweight as a confidence builder.

Now he is fighting Judah, a guy he and the world thinks that he will KO in under 4 rounds but he will struggle in this fight and people will change their opinion of Garcia after this fight.....imo.

[mathed]

Garcia, Bradley and Broner over Vilora and Froch

Viloria has three career losses, not including the one he just caught like 6 hours ago. Bradley is a 2 division champ, undefeated who beat the top guys at 140 when he was there with the exception of Khan who is crawling around in the debris of what was his career. Froch is good but he is a one division fighter....I give bonus points for fighting in different divisions and remaining undefeated.

Froch almost lost to Taylor, he prevailed well but it was a very near loss. Garcia....he is definitely not ahead of any of those guys.

[Canelo Phresh]

I got him on mine

[boliodogs]

There is no "The pound for pound list". There is as many pfp. lists as there are people that want to make one. If you are talking about the Ring Magazine pfp. list then you should say so. PFP is completely different than being champion or being #1 in your weight class. It is based on opinion of how good you think a fighter is for his size even if he has no title. You can rank Garcia as high as you want on your pfp. list because it's your list. I have never had Broner or Khan or Garcia on my top 10 pfp. I think there are enough other fighters that deserve to be rated above them pfp for them to even come close to the top 10. Matthysse is on my top 10 pfp. list and if Garcia can beat Judah and the Peterson-Matthysse winner in good style then I would certainly give him a spot in my top ten pfp. He has not done that yet. I think he will KO Judah and then get KOed by Matthysse.

[Lords]

after beating Peterson he will be top 10.

[Bee Keepz]

lmao...P4P for beating Khan