Rigondeaux "I wouldn't put Nono on the Top 5 p4p List, he is not on that level"

[CubanGuyNYC]

I dont understand either but it doesnt matter people will still say that donaire is fighter smaller guys when the statistics are right there in those pics

I was personally unaware of those figures. I get most of my stats from Boxrec. Mathebula is, of course, no surprise, but the other two fighters cited are somewhat surprising to me. I'd be curious to know how small Narvaez really is in comparison to Donaire. I would be shocked if we had figures that didn't confirm he is significantly smaller than Nonito. In any case, it's all simply of interest to me. I'm not concerned with putting Donaire down. I think he's an excellent fighter.

[Russian Crushin]

In Darchinyan's case, perhaps. Vic is listed at the same height as Donaire, but perhaps appears shorter because he crouches more than Nonito. Montiel is listed at 5' 4". That's even shorter than Rigo, whom everyone seems to think Donaire towers over.

Are you defensing this case? Guess Donaire wont get credit for Rigo either that midget cherry picker None of this matters, talk about grasping at straws

I never heard this dumb criticism with 5'8 morales.

[piojo del norte]

Donaire has to be top 10 but that is just my own opinion.

[*ANGRY CUBAN*]

Yeah..Donaire is definitely top 10 P4P. .

[CubanGuyNYC]

Are you defensing this case? Guess Donaire wont get credit for Rigo either that midget cherry picker None of this matters, talk about grasping at straws

I never heard this dumb criticism with 5'8 morales.

You've either ignored my other posts or your reading comprehension leaves a lot to be desired. I'm not defending anything. I merely mentioned what I thought Original might have meant with his post.

You'd sound a lot smarter if you put your prejudices aside.

[CubanGuyNYC]

Donaire has to be top 10 but that is just my own opinion.

Yeah..Donaire is definitely top 10 P4P. .

I think we can almost all agree Donaire's up there. There will always be some that ignore all reality. Hell, there's an active thread where some people voted for Mayweather as a greater P4P fighter than Duran. What can you say?

[DARKSEID]

So now Arce is bigger than Donaire cause he weighed more that night? Arreola and Chisora were only like 2 lbs lighter than Vitali, does that mean they were almost identical size?


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

arreola coming in as a fat-ass isn't an advantage

and neither him or chisora are anywhere the level donaire's opposition are...

just ****ing stop.. you trolls are annoying as ****

[Elotero]

That doesn't make any sense. What point is there in pretending his two best wins don't exist? Both Darch and Montiel were considered p4p at time, and there's very few fighters who can even claim they have more than one p4p win.

And enough with the Donaire fighting smaller fighters crap. Donaire is usually the smaller man, including against Montiel.

Montiel being P4P is a myth.

Had to get saved from his tuneup bout. Then Ko's Hasegawa and turns P4P. Clearly a hype fight. Real test would have been to enter the bantam tourney instead of chase Narvaez.

1 down, only nonito to go then the board is cleared of the plague.

WAR RIGO!!

[He-Yung Do]

"Take away Donaire's best wins, and his resume stinks"

"Donaire was much bigger than the guys he moved up in weight to beat for their titles"

Some real insightful and intellectual interpretations of Donaire's career in this thread

[Bigg Rigg]

Why dudes hating on Nonito for being so tall but when Caballero was ishing on Juanma and Gamboa, nobody would have gave a fudge had he beaten them. And he's 5'11 fighting 126.