Rigondeaux "I wouldn't put Nono on the Top 5 p4p List, he is not on that level"

[Divine Hammer]

That doesn't make any sense. What point is there in pretending his two best wins don't exist? Both Darch and Montiel were considered p4p at time, and there's very few fighters who can even claim they have more than one p4p win.

And enough with the Donaire fighting smaller fighters crap. Donaire is usually the smaller man, including against Montiel.

wow awesome find. i forgot montiel outweighed donaire on fight night.

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Quote:

Originally Posted by _original_

Of coarse not. But take away Darch and Montiel (which were much smaller men, mind you) and Donaire doesn't have a P4P caliber resume.

That doesn't make any sense. What point is there in pretending his two best wins don't exist? Both Darch and Montiel were considered p4p at time, and there's very few fighters who can even claim they have more than one p4p win.

And enough with the Donaire fighting smaller fighters crap. Donaire is usually the smaller man, including against Montiel.

IMAGE#1

So now Arce is bigger than Donaire cause he weighed more that night? Arreola and Chisora were only like 2 lbs lighter than Vitali, does that mean they were almost identical size?


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[DoktorSleepless]

So now Arce is bigger than Donaire cause he weighed more that night? Arreola and Chisora were only like 2 lbs lighter than Vitali, does that mean they were almost identical size?


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

In boxing, is not called WEIGHT classes?

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1PunchKOPOW!

So now Arce is bigger than Donaire cause he weighed more that night? Arreola and Chisora were only like 2 lbs lighter than Vitali, does that mean they were almost identical size?


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

In boxing, is not called WEIGHT classes?

What's that gotta do with my question?


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[bojangles1987]

Keep talking, Rigondeaux. Please keep talking.

[Pin Galarga]

This is when the inexperience come to play; If Rigo had more experience, He would be selling Donaire as a top P4P, because beating a top P4P has more value and who knows. Maybe the "experts" who makeup these lists would rank him somewhere in there after beating a #4 or #5 P4P. Now is when looking at the big picture would come to play.

[Cubanborn87]

This is when the inexperience come to play; If Rigo had more experience, He would be selling Donaire as a top P4P, because beating a top P4P has more value and who knows. Maybe the "experts" who makeup these lists would rank him somewhere in there after beating a #4 or #5 P4P. Now is when looking at the big picture would come to play.

yeah i see pro fighters do that it makes sense, on the other hand i dont think it makes a difference what he says the public will have their on opinion on donaire no matter what rigo says

[blak81]

This is when the inexperience come to play; If Rigo had more experience, He would be selling Donaire as a top P4P, because beating a top P4P has more value and who knows. Maybe the "experts" who makeup these lists would rank him somewhere in there after beating a #4 or #5 P4P. Now is when looking at the big picture would come to play.

Rigo doesnt need to hype Donaire up because 99% of boxing fans and pundits consider Donaire top 5 p4p. Donaire isn't a scrub that you need to hype up to persuade people that he is a valid or acceptable opponent.

[Light_Speed]

Of coarse not. But take away Darch and Montiel (which were much smaller men, mind you) and Donaire doesn't have a P4P caliber resume.

So what's your point exactly?

[Russian Crushin]

Of coarse not. But take away Darch and Montiel (which were much smaller men, mind you) and Donaire doesn't have a P4P caliber resume.

Take away anybodies 2 best wins and they wont have a P4P caliber resume either. Only Pac and Floyd would be left on the list, the 2 best fighters of our generation. What a noob thing to say.