if a general directs his troops into battle and they all get killed is he winning? why is a guy who is "dictacting" the pace being the ring general if he keeps getting hit..pretty crappy general you got there...hint hint hopkins-calzaghe
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Whats is YOUR interpretation of Ring Generalship?
Collapse
-
Originally posted by daggum View Postif a general directs his troops and they all get killed is he winning? why is a guy who is "dictacting" the pace being the ring general if he keeps getting hit..pretty crappy general you got there...hint hint hopkins-calzaghe
Comment
-
Originally posted by The Gambler1981 View PostNo, there is plenty going on in the ring that a real judge should be able to pick a winner about every round they score.
It isn't that hard to pick a winner if you use all the criteria available.
Picking a winner isnt hard, you're right because its the guy who scored the best more effective punches in more rounds.
Comment
-
Originally posted by PBP View PostBut that's why there's 4 factors to consider when judging a round and not just 1. Your not supposed to judge the round only on ring generalship.
Comment
-
id say the fighter who fights his pace has good ring generalship, if hes a brawler fighting a boxer but keeps the match a brawl then he has good ring generalship or vice versa
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Russian Crushin View PostClean effective punching is 95% of scoring, its not 25% each
If it was that simple that would be the only criteria to judging a fight.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Russian Crushin View PostAll of the criteria should be in your head while judging the round, you're not judging a fight just looking at just ring generalship and then just on defense and then just on aggression. If the bell rings and you cant decide a winner, there should be no "picking who to give the round to"
Picking a winner isnt hard, you're right because its the guy who scored the best more effective punches in more rounds.
You should not score even rounds, as it is not that hard to find something to separate the men based on the rules of scoring.
Comment
-
Originally posted by PBP View PostThat's true but there's many rounds (more often than not) where its difficult to measure which fighter landed the clean effective punches or back and forth rounds in which both fighters have their moments or even feeling out rounds.
If it was that simple that would be the only criteria to judging a fight.
Comment
Comment