So which elite fighters were in their prime when Pacquiao & Mayweather beat them?

[Rip Chudd]

ELITE fighters in their PRIMES?!?....all that talk about P4P top dog and best of the era bull**** is just talk huh?...its ONLY about 3 or 4 ELITE fighters in their PRIMES on their resumes COMBINED!!...Barrera and Morales went to war 3 times before Manny put hands on them....neither was in their prime AFTER those 3 classics imo....Chico had issues with the weight like Dawson had against Ward...so you have to factor that in the equation...Hatton was overrated...only one eye catching win on his resume when he fought Floyd...till this day, his best win is the Tszyu win and we all know Tszyu was at the end of his road and in his prime he would've iced Hatton

B.Hop beat more ELITE fighters in their PRIMES than BOTH of them COMBINED!!!...do the math!!

Really? Name them

[LeG00N]

Really? Name them

[SCtrojansbaby]

Pacquiao destroyed Barrera when Barrera was in his absolute prime. It is arguable the best win of the last 20 years

[G22]

when Barrera was in his absolute prime

Thats debatable. He retired back in the late 90's after losses to Junior Jones and then came back for the war in 2000 with Morales took alot out of him. He started boxing back in 1989 so to say he was in his absolute prime in 2003 after his wars and losses is questionable at best

[Jimmy 23]

Pacquiao:
Marquez, Bradley, Cotto, Clottey
Mayweather
Corrales, Castillo, Hatton

[dc3383]

It's assbackwards to say Hatton was in his prime vs Manny but wasn't vs Floyd. Barerra was shopworn vs Manny it was still a excellent win I was shock by the beating he put on him but he wasn't in his prime.

[revs1227]

Bradley isn't an elite fighter anyway.

?????

floyd beat corrales and castillo in their prime
pacquiao beat marquez in his prime

so youll count castillo win but not the bradley loss

pac
marquez
Barrera
bradley'
cotto
clottey


floyd
ortiz
hatton
castillo
corrales

[revs1227]

Really? Name them

i agree with b hop statement


pascal
pavlik
tarver
tito
oscar
johnson

[LeG00N]

i agree with b hop statement


pascal
pavlik
tarver
tito
oscar
johnson

[Rip Chudd]

i agree with b hop statement


pascal
pavlik
tarver
tito
oscar
johnson

You do know that question was "which ELITE fighters were in their prime" do you not?

Again let me stress the word "ELITE".

So you can take Pascal, Pavlik, Johnson, and Tarver off that list. I'll give you Trinidad and Hoya, you can make a case for those names.