Has Vitali ever beaten someone better than Devon Alexander? Interesting isn't it?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • ArtThouFurious?
    Banned
    Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
    • Mar 2012
    • 234
    • 46
    • 6
    • 288

    #11
    Originally posted by Harry Balls
    Yes on all. And that doesn't mean they're very good, just that they are just as good or better than Devon who lost to Bradley, Kotelnik and Matthysse.
    He beat Kotelnik and Matthysse in close fights that could've went either way. Go look up the press row scores for both fights, they were split in both instances.

    And there's no shame in losing to Bradley, seeing as though Bradley is the 1st NON-ATG boxer in over a decade to give Pacquiao a reasonably competitive fight.

    Alexander's resume and quality of competition faced shitz all over the gentlemen that you claimed were superior boxers.

    Vitali doesn't even have the p4p equivalent of a Devon Alexander on his resume, which is beyond sad.

    Comment

    • Earl-Hickey
      Banned
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Nov 2009
      • 29031
      • 2,832
      • 1,384
      • 297,750

      #12
      Originally posted by ArtThouFurious?
      He beat Kotelnik and Matthysse in close fights that could've went either way. Go look up the press row scores for both fights, they were split in both instances.

      And there's no shame in losing to Bradley, seeing as though Bradley is the 1st NON-ATG boxer in over a decade to give Pacquiao a reasonably competitive fight.

      Alexander's resume and quality of competition faced shitz all over the gentlemen that you claimed were superior boxers.

      Vitali doesn't even have the p4p equivalent of a Devon Alexander on his resume, which is beyond sad.
      Matthyse-Alexander was close

      Kotelnik-Alexander was not and was a bad robbery

      Comment

      • Barry Halls
        Mi Vida Loca
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Dec 2010
        • 4141
        • 189
        • 162
        • 10,607

        #13
        Originally posted by ArtThouFurious?
        He beat Kotelnik and Matthysse in close fights that could've went either way. Go look up the press row scores for both fights, they were split in both instances.

        And there's no shame in losing to Bradley, seeing as though Bradley is the 1st NON-ATG boxer in over a decade to give Pacquiao a reasonably competitive fight.

        Alexander's resume and quality of competition faced shitz all over the gentlemen that you claimed were superior boxers.

        Vitali doesn't even have the p4p equivalent of a Devon Alexander on his resume, which is beyond sad.
        Why should i look at press row scores when i'm more than capable of judging the fights myself?

        Adamek beat Cunningham (once) Arreola, Chambers, Banks. This is better than what Devon has done.

        Corrie Sanders beat an arguably ATG heavyweight and the rest of his resumé holds about as much weight as Devons.

        Gomez dominated cruiserweight for a long time.

        Not to mention i never said they're greater than Devon (though they probably are) i said they're better. It's about skillset. And Devon is a ****ty mentally weak fighter.

        His best legit win is against a shot Junior Witter.

        Comment

        • ArtThouFurious?
          Banned
          Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
          • Mar 2012
          • 234
          • 46
          • 6
          • 288

          #14
          Originally posted by Harry Balls
          Why should i look at press row scores when i'm more than capable of judging the fights myself?
          People that receive a paycheck to cover boxing, scoring the fight LIVE from the same vantage point as the judges > You watching the fight on a shitty, choppy, stream in a internet cafe.

          Adamek beat Cunningham (once) Arreola, Chambers, Banks. This is better than what Devon has done.
          Arreola is a fringe contender, with not one single meaningful Heavyweight win, and Adamek went life and death with him. And Adamek didn't beat Chambers, that fight was a worse robbery than any Devon Alexander fight.

          Devon Alexander's Welterweight resume > Adamek's Heavyweight resume.

          I don't see how this can be disputed.

          Corrie Sanders beat an arguably ATG heavyweight and the rest of his resumé holds about as much weight as Devons.
          Corrie Sanders has never beaten an ATG Heavyweight. Complete fantasy.

          His only meaningful win in his entire Heavyweight career is beating a guy that even Ross Puritty was able to knock out.


          Gomez dominated cruiserweight for a long time.
          Gomez didn't dominate shit at Cruiserweight. He didn't even fight any of the other top Cruiserweights and feasted on unranked tomato cans during his short stint as paper titlist at Cruiserweight.

          And if i'm telling tall tales, why don't you list out his top 5 wins at Cruiserweight so we can have a good laugh.

          Or better yet, his best win at Heavyweight.

          A 300,000 year old Oliver McCall?

          Volodymyr Virchis?

          Comment

          • thuggery
            proper rock slanga'
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Jan 2012
            • 10309
            • 717
            • 1,342
            • 18,054

            #15
            Some people will just defend Floyd with all of their might

            It's a little pathetic.

            Comment

            • ShamrockXpress
              Interim Champion
              Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
              • Jan 2013
              • 550
              • 55
              • 16
              • 9,697

              #16
              Why is a klitschko even in discussion here? If floyd wanted to unify why not do it with tim Bradley? Didn't he own Devon? But ye he does have big wins, he hugged Marcos maidana to death, the win over bailey? Hopefully they fight in st Louis and floyd gets robbed the way PAC did against desert storm and we can laugh at the two B!tch3s for robbing us of an era defining fight a few years ago

              Comment

              • Mr. Fantastic
                Banned
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • May 2008
                • 19036
                • 527
                • 1,328
                • 20,027

                #17
                Originally posted by thuggery
                Some people will just defend Floyd with all of their might

                It's a little pathetic.
                Little? Nothing is more pathetic than having "deadly" hands and hitting a woman in front of your kids. Since they want to justify Floyd's ways of ducking prime WWs back in the days.

                Comment

                • ArtThouFurious?
                  Banned
                  Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                  • Mar 2012
                  • 234
                  • 46
                  • 6
                  • 288

                  #18
                  Originally posted by ShamrockXpress
                  Why is a klitschko even in discussion here? If floyd wanted to unify why not do it with tim Bradley
                  ? Didn't he own Devon? But ye he does have big wins, he hugged Marcos maidana to death, the win over bailey? Hopefully they fight in st Louis and floyd gets robbed the way PAC did against desert storm and we can laugh at the two B!tch3s for robbing us of an era defining fight a few years ago
                  They don't fight in the same boxing league.

                  Floyd: Golden Boy/Al Haymon boxing circuit

                  Bradley: Top Rank boxing circuit

                  Sadly, this is what boxing has been reduced to.

                  Protip: He's not fighting Devon Alexander. And you would have to be rather nieve to believe this fight is going thru.

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  TOP