Should be a TKO victory?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • clmags12
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jan 2010
    • 1368
    • 206
    • 200
    • 7,231

    #11
    Originally posted by Nekeneg
    ^^bump...

    Opinions...??
    Bro, i understand where you are coming from BUT the broken nose came from an accidental head butt. Too unfair of an advantage from an accidental injury.

    Comment

    • Nekeneg
      Contender
      Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
      • Nov 2009
      • 112
      • 17
      • 1
      • 6,187

      #12
      Originally posted by clmags12
      Bro, i understand where you are coming from BUT the broken nose came from an accidental head butt. Too unfair of an advantage from an accidental injury.
      Thanks for replying. I was just genuinely curious, that is why I asked. I mean technically speaking it should have been really a TKO or maybe not, I dunno.. But I see your point as well.

      Comment

      • Hougigo
        Gossip Girl
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Sep 2011
        • 38755
        • 730
        • 236
        • 47,223

        #13
        Originally posted by Nekeneg
        Thanks for replying. I was just genuinely curious, that is why I asked. I mean technically speaking it should have been really a TKO or maybe not, I dunno.. But I see your point as well.
        Technically speaking no it shouldn't.
        It was an accidental headbutt, if the fighter is deemed unfit or unwilling to fight then it goes to the scorecards after 5.

        Comment

        • Nekeneg
          Contender
          Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
          • Nov 2009
          • 112
          • 17
          • 1
          • 6,187

          #14
          Originally posted by hougigo
          Technically speaking no it shouldn't.
          It was an accidental headbutt, if the fighter is deemed unfit or unwilling to fight then it goes to the scorecards after 5.
          True, the ringside physician should be able to assess if a fighter is fit to continue fighting and stop the fight if he needs to, however for this fight it seemed like the decision to stop the fight came from Garcia's corner.

          Comment

          • ThePunchingBag
            Rolling with the punches.
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Apr 2009
            • 5766
            • 192
            • 55
            • 12,300

            #15
            Originally posted by MR. LARRYX
            threads like this make me wonder how long some people have been following boxing,whats next if you drop kick a man and he cant continue you win?
            Holy ****, man I can't believe the kind of fans BScene has now.

            They don't even know the rules and think you can win by fouling your opponent.

            WTF happened to this place?

            Comment

            • -PBP-
              32 Time World Champion
              Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
              • Jan 2012
              • 24107
              • 836
              • 635
              • 34,297

              #16
              Originally posted by Nekeneg
              He was asked if he wanted to continue fighting, and his corner said no. He quit. Point deduction would have suffice but because of the ringside official's bad call, he got away with quitting.
              The issue becomes that his opponent would have been given an advantage as the result of a foul. You can't win a fight by fouling your opponent.

              The only way a TKO should be awarded is if the damage is caused as the result of a punch.

              Comment

              Working...
              TOP