HOF or ATG? Fighters on the Line

[AztecWanker]

Pacquiao and Wladimir are the only ATGs in that list.

Fraud is just that, a Fraud.

JMM beat only one good fighter. After 3 tries.

Oscar is con artist as well.

[revs1227]

pac is atg

floyd can be

rest are hof marquez being the greatest

[A-Wolf]

Marquez and Pacquiao ATG. They faced and defeated the best and most dangerous talent of their time. Mayweather had the potential for ATG. Unfortunately he failed to face and/or defeat the greatest and most dangerous fighters available to him. Consistently.

[edgarg]

I believe only Manny Pacquiao and just possibly Wladimir Klitschko. The others are on the edge and not there yet, maybe will but likely won't.

[edgarg]

Depends on what you go by Top 50 or Top 100 ATG?

It shouldn't depend on anything like that.An ATG is an ATG regardless of how many there are. As the years roll on, the numbers will naturally grow... And another point, since the addition of the extra divisions that will make an increase, Hagler and Monzon are ATG and never stepped outside their division.

[Wiley Hyena]

I believe only Manny Pacquiao and just possibly Wladimir Klitschko. The others are on the edge and not there yet, maybe will but likely won't.

Wlad has alot of work to do.

[Wiley Hyena]

pac is atg

floyd can be

rest are hof marquez being the greatest

This is the way I see it, too.
This poll is fairly surprising.

[4Corners]

Mayweather and Pacquiao are in the Top 50, no doubt about it. They are certified Top 50 ATG's.

Marquez is right around there, I don't know if I'd place him in the Top 50, but he's close. De La Hoya isn't in the Top 50, but he's clearly in the Top 100. Wlad isn't in the Top 100 all-time, no way.

But I consider Top 100 ATG's, so I'd say Floyd and Manny are clearly the two highest ATG's on here, than Marquez, than Oscar. Wlad is a HOF in my book, but no way is he Top 100.

[TheBoxingBanger]

@ko

I'm both a Pacquiao fan and Mayweather fan, I don't swing pro Money/anti-Pacman nor Pro Pacman/Anti-Money.

... well said.

[Wiley Hyena]

... well said.

Ok, back up to the top.