Castillo v Floyd I "It's not the fight we saw"

[Derranged]

Oh give it a ****in rest already. A few times a month this fight gets a new thread, same old crap.

That fight was anything but easy for either guy, could've went either way. People seriously need to get over this already.

[dc3383]

Castillo almost killed Floyd is everybody happy now

[The Big Dunn]

Just reviewed Jose Luis Castillo v Floyd Mayweather I. Lederman score card: 115-111 Castillo. Judges scorecards: 115-111 Floyd. Lampley: "It's not the fight we saw."

I saw Castillo win rather easily. What fight did you see?

So is this what we can expect from you until Manny returns in September? I mean its been 3 weeks now, the concussion Manny suffered hasn't lingered as long as your emotions. Relitigating floyd castillo for the 10,000 time is not something doctor's recommend for a broken heart.

[kiDynamite92]

Was a closer fight than what the judges scorecards suggest, just shows how under appreciated the art of body punching has become. I gave the first fight to Castillo, was a close fight tho but I thought Castillo done a little bit more. The second fight was the opposite, thought Floyd won that one, but I saw a different Castillo in that fight, one that was more worried about the judging than the actual fight. But the real question is, would Floyd be a big as he is now, if the judges scored it for Castillo in the first.......

[p4p-champ]

Just reviewed Jose Luis Castillo v Floyd Mayweather I. Lederman score card: 115-111 Castillo. Judges scorecards: 115-111 Floyd. Lampley: "It's not the fight we saw."

I saw Castillo win rather easily. What fight did you see?

Again bro? You should watch some other fights and stop obsessing over the past. You should stick to one account while your at it.

[BTTAG145]

I guess Mayweather is the first fighter in history to get a close controversial decision victory.

[Rapid Counter]

I had Floyd losing by a couple of rounds. I feel Castillo was robbed of the win. I also feel that Mayweather's shoulder injury was legit and it definitely played a factor in the fight. Floyd shouldn't have his 0 now but that's not because Castillo is a better boxer.....he clearly isn't.

[Marvellous1]

Was a closer fight than what the judges scorecards suggest, just shows how under appreciated the art of body punching has become. I gave the first fight to Castillo, was a close fight tho but I thought Castillo done a little bit more. The second fight was the opposite, thought Floyd won that one, but I saw a different Castillo in that fight, one that was more worried about the judging than the actual fight. But the real question is, would Floyd be a big as he is now, if the judges scored it for Castillo in the first.......

It's a question nobody can really answer. Kind of like the De La Hoya/Whitaker situation, where Oscar candidly admitted on tv that their result went the way of the man they thought would make more money. Who's to say what Oscar would've achieved or not had the decision gone the other way? We'll never know.

[Luilun]

Just reviewed Jose Luis Castillo v Floyd Mayweather I. Lederman score card: 115-111 Castillo. Judges scorecards: 115-111 Floyd. Lampley: "It's not the fight we saw."

I saw Castillo win rather easily. What fight did you see?

Castillo 8 rounds Floyd 4 rounds and Castillo being the Champ that fight should have never gone to Floyd. But Hbo knew if Floyd lost his career as a future PPV star would have been a train wreck so the judges had to rob Castillo. ( Boxing is a Dirty Business )

[Marvellous1]

Castillo 8 rounds Floyd 4 rounds and Castillo being the Champ that fight should have never gone to Floyd. But Hbo knew if Floyd lost his career as a future PPV star would have been a train wreck so the judges had to rob Castillo. ( Boxing is a Dirty Business )

Castillo could always have settled the return by a bone chilling, heart stopping, face planking, canvas kissing knockout. That's how you settle being on the wrong end of a scorecard. Juan Manuel Marquez learned that, didn't he?