Whose win over Pac is bigger than the other?

[4Corners]

Morales, but both are good. Pacquiao was prime in 2005, he was past prime-still good in 2012.

[pnksntdead]

lol at manny being prime in '05. physical prime, arguably, but he was still too heavily reliant on his left then. marquez beat a more complete fighter. pacs previous fight with bradley was unimpressive but he looked pretty much like the old pac before jmm ko'd him. also, jmm was getting hurt badly in the fight to, which makes his ko'd pretty epic.

[FeFist]

I say morales. Why? Because he clearly beat PAC first (good fight by the way).
First fight PAC had with Marquez was close. Marquez beat PAC convincingly in the 3rd fight I believe.

What you're saying does not make sense. Marquez gained a clear victory over Pacquiao by knocking him the fuck out.

[Bermuda]

hard to say..i'd slightly favor erik morales' win though. pac was younger and in his physical prime when he met morales.. and pac was pretty much steam rolling through his opponents at that point...whereas the pac that marquez beat was seen by many at that point as being on the decline (physically and mentally). the height of pac's career was at 2009-2010 though.

[ElBossHogg™]

Morales beat a prime (although hasnt peak) Pacquaio. Marquez officially KO'd a past prime Pacquaio.

So my vote will be Morales.

[Wiley Hyena]

Morales....

[CHOWWOKKA]

Well Morales beat a poisoned Pacquiao who had the wrong socks on = Not a good win

And Marquez needed to be on steroids to knock out an old religious unmotivated Pacqquiao, who was probably poisoned and had on wrong socks = Not a good win.

It's a draw

[G22]

Marquez win was more emphatic and on teh face of it youd have to give him the edge but when you look deeper - Erik beat Pac who went onto greatness whereas Marquez beat Pac when he was coming off a loss and hadnt looked good in years. Also Marquez' win is clouded in su****ion because he had so much more power in that fight than he did in his previous 50 fights. That doesnt happen suddleny at 40 years of age. A man who is willing to drink his own urine is willing to do anything to get an advantage so I reckon his new "conditioner" played a part in that fight.

[MaD RoBoT]

bump for more opinions