Who will be remembered as the greatest fighter of these?

[The Hammer]

Probably Manny Pacquiao.

[Pudgemeister]

Seems like its mostly between Pac vs Jones. Any arguments for either side? I personally see RJ as greater..

[4Corners]

Are we talking resume or H2H???

Holyfield is the greatest of these guys in my opinion. H2H and skills, it's probably Jones or Mayweather.

[El_Forklift]

All ATG's but only 1 has knocked another ATG out from that list...



which is why he gets my vote

good way to see it

[edgarg]

Probably Manny Pacquiao.

Jones, Holyfield, Pacquiao, Chavez, Hopkins, Mayweather, Marquez.

No question about the first 4. Jones was unique in our lifetimes, Holyfield had a terrific resume and fought anybody, Pacquiao did a one-of-a-kind blizzard through 8 divisions, Chavez is the greatest boxer that the top boxing nation Mexico has ever produced. Hopkins, crafty and dirty....but rotten to watch; just his age, and was lucky to get poor competition. Mayweather a fine craftsma but a very careful picker, Marquez a good solid all-round guy with his by far best win at a late age.

[edgarg]

Probably Manny Pacquiao.

Jones, Holyfield, Pacquiao, Chavez, Hopkins, Mayweather, Marquez.

No question about the first 4. Jones was unique in our lifetimes, Holyfield had a terrific resume and fought anybody, Pacquiao did a one-of-a-kind blizzard through 8 divisions, Chavez is the greatest boxer that the top boxing nation Mexico has ever produced. Hopkins, crafty and dirty....but rotten to watch; just his age, and was lucky to get poor competition. Mayweather a fine craftsma but a very careful picker, Marquez a good solid all-round guy with his by far best win at a late age.

[edgarg]

Probably Manny Pacquiao.

Jones, Holyfield, Pacquiao, Chavez, Hopkins, Mayweather, Marquez.

No question about the first 4. Jones was unique in our lifetimes, Holyfield had a terrific resume and fought anybody, Pacquiao did a one-of-a-kind blizzard through 8 divisions, Chavez is the greatest boxer that the top boxing nation Mexico has ever produced. Hopkins, crafty and dirty....and rotten to watch; just his age, and was lucky to get poor competition. Mayweather a fine craftsma but a very careful picker, Marquez a good solid all-round guy with his by far best win at a late age.

[UTEP]

Julio Cesar Chavez Sr. and it's not even close

[Skittlez]

Lennox Lewis ranks higher than half of those guys on that ****** list.. and he actually beat the living shyt out of Holyfield..


****** ****** list..


Even shot Lewis would have knocked out Jones if Roy had fought him after Ruiz.