Most Underrated and Overrated Boxers Today.

[Frank Ducketts]

I may seem disingenuous, but don't fault me. It's the thread topic, lmao!

[Jack Napier]

Maniac's list has some hits and some misses

overrated

Garcia - Khan's a good win, but 2 wins over geriatric Terrible? ish
Rigo - hyped for amateur pedigree, done nothing as a pro
Floyd - hasn't done shit in yrs, p4p is like a catchphrase for him
Broner - getting ranked for his potential, not what he's actually done

underrated

Wlad - not his fault HW is weak, he's boxing's most dominant man by far
Ward - so what if he's always in Oakland? his fights are never close
Nonito - too much flak for struggling with Math, taking over south of LW
Froch - lacks skills, but so what? he still wins, and in exciting fashion

[boricuajr23]

overated:
Rios
D. garcia
Broner

Underated:
Viloria
Bradley
A. Dirrell

[B Phontain]

overated:
Rios
D. garcia
Broner

Underated:
Viloria
Bradley
A. Dirrell

I kinda think D.Garcia is right where he needs to be. I just think people dont doubt him as much as they used to (and rightfully so).

[studentofthegam]

"One of the best combination punchers of all time. Even better than Joe Louis (who I hold in high regard)"

This part, also complete rubbish.

That part is true. In the image of "Finito" he may be the best Ive seen this era in a fire fight

So what exactly is the key point? Is he overrated or underrated??? Are you/him trying to imply he is only overrated above 135 and not at 35 and below? If that's the case why would he be on the underrated list? His body of work can't concurrently be underrated and overrated?

It just goes to show the boys talent when people have to dissect his career in order to push silly agendas.

Most overrated (At this stage of their careers);

Lara
Golovkin
Rigondeaux

They're top 3 IMO.

These are my pics exactly. Not that they lack talent. Either could lose their next fight and become the forgotten.

[PureBoxingCEO]

Overrated = Broner, Rios
Underrated = Matthysse, Special K

[TX_BOXNG]

Golovkin is very overrated n Mares is underrated

[CityByTheBay]

Everyone does.

Not everyone Bro!

[Luilun]

The Most overrated is the guy who can pull the curtains over his pathetic fan base by masterfully cherry picken name opponents who are no longer in in their prime and only face little guys who call him out but will not face a Primed guys his size or bigger who's calling him out. Without naming a name I'm sure we all know whom I'm talking about

[Ringlife]

Maniac's list has some hits and some misses

overrated

Garcia - Khan's a good win, but 2 wins over geriatric Terrible? ish
Rigo - hyped for amateur pedigree, done nothing as a pro
Floyd - hasn't done shit in yrs, p4p is like a catchphrase for him
Broner - getting ranked for his potential, not what he's actually done

underrated

Wlad - not his fault HW is weak, he's boxing's most dominant man by far
Ward - so what if he's always in Oakland? his fights are never close
Nonito - too much flak for struggling with Math, taking over south of LW
Froch - lacks skills, but so what? he still wins, and in exciting fashion

What he said just not that part about Wlad.I think Viloria is underrated.