Adrian Broner vs Brian Viloria

[MVOLT]

who belongs on the p4p list between these two?

[Jack Napier]

Viloria has done more
Broner getting ranked on potential, not accomplishments
he has time to do more work, but Demarco alone isn't enough
Marquez, Miranda, Segura>Demarco

[Garofalo]

who belongs on the p4p list between these two?

I don't like niether but broner has been on HBO fighting HBO quality fighters. Who has Viloria beaten that's been on HBO or PPV? and when's the last time if ever, that viloria has fought in HBO? and don't tell me that HBO shows crappy fighters/fights because they show only the best.

[LeG00N]

Vilora, Guerrero, Mares, Froch > Broner

[DeadLikeMe]

Broner for fighting in closer to a relevant division.

[Garofalo]

Mvolt and I are not voting because he made a claim bet on my according to him that Viloria is better than Broner. I just think he hates broner.

[happyman]

Vilora........

[MVOLT]

Viloria has done more
Broner getting ranked on potential, not accomplishments
he has time to do more work, but Demarco alone isn't enough
Marquez, Miranda, Segura>Demarco

that's my argument as well

[teddycanyon]

Viloria, although I'm a little reluctant to make him top ten also, he's very inconsistent with his performances, he just seems to be on a hot streak now

[puga]

viloria and he should've been there for a while too ..when segura beat calderon , he got the spot right on ..viloria did more than that..beat p4p #8 guy, the number 1 guy in his division and got a revenge from a loss...