Ok lets see your new p4p lists

[The Big Dunn]

1-Ward
2-Floyd
3-Martinez
4-Marquez
5-Pacquiao (you can't just erase his accomplishments)
6-Donaire
7-Wlad
7-Bradley
8-Vitali
9-Mares
10-Froch

respectfully, manny can't possibly still be top 5 given his last 3 fights. I think he won both jmm 3 and the bradley fight, but he hasn't looked like a top 5 p4p in them.

[Larry the boss]

To take Manny out due to his one Ko lost is dumb! But hey, thats what haters do. I understand!

1,JMM
2,Martinez
3,Manny
4,Ward
5,Donaire
6,Wald
7,Vitali
8,Moreno
9,Froch
10,Dodie Boy {In place of Floyd}

Roy Jones was taken off of the list for his ko loss to Tarver..went from p4p#1 to not even top to..and Tarver was p4p top 10

[Bermuda]

1. Andre Ward
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Nonito Donaire
4. Sergio Martinez
5. Floyd Mayweather
6. Manny Pacquiao
7. Wladimir Klitschko
8. Vitali Klitschko
9. Abner Mares
10. Brian Viloria

[BlackHat]

Roy Jones was taken off of the list for his ko loss to Tarver..went from p4p#1 to not even top to..and Tarver was p4p top 10

Did he? I can only check the year end rating when he lost to both tarver and johnson.

[oc9979]

According to the fans at boxingscene.com
Miguel Cotto vs Timothy Bradley @ 154: Who Wins?
06/13/2012

102 votes for Cotto
7 votes for Bradley

Cotto vs Bradley at 147. who wins?
04/09/2012

59 votes for Cotto
21 votes for Bradley

[BigStereotype]

According to the fans at boxingscene.com
Miguel Cotto vs Timothy Bradley @ 154: Who Wins?
06/13/2012

102 votes for Cotto
7 votes for Bradley

Cotto vs Bradley at 147. who wins?
04/09/2012

59 votes for Cotto
21 votes for Bradley

LALALALALALA he's not listening bro

Time to face facts...

Wdksab

[UrGonnaLooos]

1-Ward
2-Floyd
3-Marquez
4-Martinez
5-Donaire
6-Wlad
7-Bradley
8-Vitali
9-Froch
10-Mares

P4P
1. Ward
2. Wlad
3. Martinez
4. Floyd
5. Marquez
6. Donaire
7. Froch
8. Vitali
9. Bradley
10. Mares

[techliam]

P4P
1. Ward
2. Wlad
3. Martinez
4. Floyd
5. Marquez
6. Donaire
7. Froch
8. Vitali
9. Bradley
10. Mares

Just a question, how can you rank Bradley over Pacquiao? Last time I checked, official bad decisions weren't considered into head-to-head subjective comparisons, considering we have the fight to look at.

[-Johannes-]

How long till they change this?
http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/view.php?pg=pound

[Bermuda]

still shocks me that no one thinks brian viloria is finally top ten p4p worthy......