Who is better: Brian Magee or Kelly Pavlik

[ShoulderRoll]

Right now, or in their respective primes?

Right now.

[J-Smooth]

Magee? The guy who got his ass raped by bute? Pavlik no doubt...

[Weebler I]

I dunno, Pavlik looked pretty laboured against Rosinsky and he looked drunk in his last interview.

In his prime though, Pavlik was better.

[BattlingNelson]

Does Pavlik have a meaningfull win in the last five years? Before tonight Magee was clearly the better fighter. As it is now after the whooping he got from Kessler, they are about equal.

They are both rehabbing their liver.

[ShoulderRoll]

So 2 rounds ruined Magee?

I'll say this much. The current version of Pavlik wouldn't have folded from every bodyshot Kessler threw.

[gaz26]

Pavlick has looked awful since coming back, and i was disappointed in magee tonight, anyone he fights now will go straight to the body, Pavlik won't even win a rd vs ward, i think ward is wasting a few months of his career going after pavlik.