Jose Luis Castillo VS Floyd Mayweather I, Who really won??

[ManOfVictory]

Castillo won that fight........and i was lucky enough to be present.


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

[Beercules]

Using compubox total punches to decide who won a fight is like saying the candidate for president that gets the most total votes wins the election.

Dunn look at the poll. Stop with your corny presidential election nonsense

Floyd.. He won all the early rounds.. It really wasn't til rounds 8,9,10 when catillo started to really putting it on floyd..

Floyd won 4 clear rounds. Round 10 was 10-8 for Castillo.

Castillo pushed the pace, Floyd threw jabs, Castillo power punches.

[Memo Heroidia]

compubox stats clearly photoshopped! all lies and propaganda! stop hatin'

[arraamis]

[gauze]

i scored that fight 119-107 for castillo

[Beercules]

compubox stats clearly photoshopped! all lies and propaganda! stop hatin'

Compubox don't matter anymore doe. *instert Dunns comparison to Presidental elections *

Did I force you to click this thread? I bumped it because I was disputing with another user earlier.

[ramses07]

lol i forgot how bad the judges score cards were

[The Big Dunn]

Dunn look at the poll. Stop with your corny presidential election nonsense





Floyd won 4 clear rounds. Round 10 was 10-8 for Castillo.

Castillo pushed the pace, Floyd threw jabs, Castillo power punches.

Call it corny if you have to. But it's 100% correct. Compubox counts punches landed in rounds, not rounds won. Rounds won is what a decision win is based on. A boxing fan should know that.

I looked at who voted Castillo. That tells me who actually thought Castillo one and who was just using the poll in their never ending hatred of Floyd.

[Beercules]

Call it corny if you have to. But it's 100% correct. Compubox counts punches landed in rounds, not rounds won. Rounds won is what a decision win is based on. A boxing fan should know that.

I looked at who voted Castillo. That tells me who actually thought Castillo one and who was just using the poll in their never ending hatred of Floyd.

So if fighter A lands more power punches than fighter B in certain rounds, thus winning the rounds fighter A should win the fight? Because he threw some jabs?

Floyd wasn't even his slick usual self.

Or if we get into a fight and I land 100+ power punches on you, I shouldn't win the fight?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Dunn look at the poll. Stop with your corny presidential election nonsense





Floyd won 4 clear rounds. Round 10 was 10-8 for Castillo.

Castillo pushed the pace, Floyd threw jabs, Castillo power punches.

Round 11 was 10-8 floyd, plus floyd won the 12th..

Floyd won the first 4, castillo didn't sweep 5,6,7

Do the math