broner vs prime sugar shane mayweather and whitaker@135lbs

[The Viper]

Not saying he could beat them, cause in my opinions there the best lightweights in the last twenty years....but could he hold his own against them?

[Mato o Muero]

No they would dominate him.

[Capaedia]

Castillo is the best lightweight since Whitaker.

Not Mosley. Who did he beat to prove that against? I think he was a better welterweight than lightweight, his resume certainly backs that up.

And Broner has only had one fight at LW, how are we supposed to judge this?

[nachorjj]

Broner loss against this 3

[gmc_rfc_06]

Broner is looking a very good fighter with all the tools required.

He's not ****ing with any version of Mayweather, not a chance. Not sure how he takes a punch to survive being stopped by Mosley (I'd go Mosley though) and his skill level isn't proven against top guys to suggest he could deal with Whitaker.

[dibzvincent143]

Duran should be there. Duran is the best lightweight and would KO any of the three. Broner has a lot to prove and his on his way to greatness, Props to him and I hope he'll do it right what floyd didn't.

[TX_BOXNG]

i think they would beat him

[Dr Rumack]

Duran should be there. Duran is the best lightweight and would KO any of the three. Broner has a lot to prove and his on his way to greatness, Props to him and I hope he'll do it right what floyd didn't.

Duran last fought lightweight in 1978, but yeah, he starches just about anyone at 135lbs.

[Ryn0]

Mosley at LW is a different beast, Roger Mayweather (or Floyd Sr.) I can't remember who said it described the two versions the best.

Mosley at lightweight was like a machine gun, combinations movement, constant punching. When he moved up to Welterweight he was more like a *******, looking for that big overhand right or left hook. Mosley at Welter became a lot more predictable but was still a great fighter.

I'd pick both Mosley and Whittaker over Broner, Broner has had one fight at 135 and Demarco isn't anywhere near Whittaker or Mosleys class.

[bojangles1987]

Broner doesn't deserve to be mentioned on the same page as Whitaker, let alone the same paragraph or sentence.

I think him and Mosley would come down to Broner's chin. If he could take some bombs, that could be a really good fight. No way I'd pick Broner though, Mosley deserves more respect than that.