Miguel Cotto at his peak. Would you consider him a GREAT fighter?

[Thread Stealer]

I rank him in the "very good" category with guys like Jose Luis Castillo....as far as welterweights go, slightly below guys like Simon Brown.

Very good, not "great", which I reserve for fighters like Mayweather, Pacquiao, Hagler, etc....or for guys who are great for a short period like Curry.